Tuesday, March 06, 2012

Being a Creative Director

I've been watching a lot of TV lately in this period of no-job and no-work.

A few conclusions:

Firstly, Indian serials are insanely bad.
I mean they truly plumb depths of awfulness that have to be seen to be believed. The acting is grotesque, reminiscent of the 60s style of movie acting. Some of the actresses are reasonably attractive, but, for the most part - especially the older women - are just plain gruesome. As for the men, a bigger collection of cardboard cut-outs would be difficult to find.

Secondly, television news in English has completely lost the plot
For the last three days, all they've been covering is projections of what the polls will deliver. They then debate what will happen if the polls are accurate (a big, fat 'if'). In the process, they are not only manufacturing news, they are ignoring the real happening news. For example, it doesn't seem to matter enough to Arnab Goswami to focus his histrionic mock outrage on what is happening with the lawyers in Bangalore. How utterly corrupt they are and how they are flouting the law at every turn. What matters more is an opinion poll that cannot accurately predict what will happen two days hence.

Today, when the results have been announced, they conduct the same interviews with the same set of nitwits posing the same dim questions.

The only difference is that they now have the real numbers to talk about. And even that seems iffy, because NDTV, TimesNow, HeadlinesToday and CNN-IBN are all reporting different figures.

Thirdly, Indian advertising still follows Sturgeon's Law
I learnt this from Harlan Ellison's 'The Glass Teat" which profoundly changed my life. Sturgeon's Law states that 90% of everything is crap. There is only 10% of anything that is good, worthwhile and true in the world. My belief (and Harlan's) is that you should strive to produce stuff that is part of the 10%. But that's an aside.

Sturgeon's Law had two corollaries and they apply to advertising as well (I'm paraphrasing here);

1. The existence of immense quantities of trash in Indian advertising is admitted and it is regrettable; but it is no more unnatural than the existence of trash anywhere.

2. The best Indian advertising is as good as the best advertising in any country.

However, I still believe some of the Vintellicepts I did at Vertebrand was as good as the 10% in current India advertising. I mean the stuff that isn't utter crap.

So do I think I could still crack a creative director's job. Yes, my liege. I could probably apply good boot to the gluteus maximus of most the current run of creative directors.

Of course, this is theorizing; nobody's going to offer me a job now (too old).

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Thank you for great articulate else could anyone get that kind of information in such a perfect way of writing.
Advocates in Bangalore