Your consumer may be your wife, but she’s not the sun, moon and stars. She is not the last word on branding. In fact, her opinion may cause you to arrive at entirely the wrong branding decisions.
That’s why a consumer’s opinion is only one input – albeit an important one – that you must use to build a brand identity.
Your advertising agency will probably add the fact that your brand must consider the competition – which again is true, but it’s still only part of the story.
So what else is there?
The answer is for one, your own company’s DNA; its philosophical underpinnings and the history that govern your day-to-day dealings.
What kind of company are you?
Are you an aggressive, hard-going, even abrasive company? Then, a brand strategy that emphasizes what a warm, generous, giving brand you are is quite simply ludicrous.
Your people will not be able to deliver on the ‘warm, generous and giving’ when their training, evaluation and inclination – and probably their recruitment – is based on entirely the opposite standards.
So, although there is one customer-facing area – advertising and communication – in which you can communicate your brand promise, in most other customer-facing areas the brand will fail miserably to deliver.
Instead of positioning a brand from that company as being soft and mushy, it would make a lot more sense to take up a position in the area of ‘we are extremely aggressive – on your behalf’. That way, when customers meet your people, they come in expecting aggressive, hard-going, even abrasive behaviour.
Even when your brand is an FMCG and the theory is that the company’s values have no relevance, there has to be a match.
If the Company’s philosophy and the brand’s values do not match, the brand will behave in an inconsistent manner – which disconcerts consumers.
Take an example of two FMCG companies. One has a philosophy of bringing ‘demonstrably better’ products to the consumer. The other comes from the point of view of a trader – buy-low, sell-high.
If this is the essential genetic deposition of the company, a brand from the ‘trader’ company is unlikely to be a superior product. So, attempting to position a brand from the ‘trader’ company as one that provides a ‘better than’ experience would be a non-starter.
A Company that is genetically predisposed to creating ‘demonstrably superior’ products, on the other hand, is more likely to sustain a brand that promises superior products.
In sum, brand must incorporate a company’s strengths and acknowledge its weaknesses.
The second aspect that is often left in a sort of limbo is the environment – nobody bothers to answer the question, ‘how will the brand behave in the light of environmental changes?’
They say that a cell-phone is basically a small computer with a radio attached. If that’s so, how will all the cell-phone brands work in an era when there will be a rapid convergence of communication, entertainment and information into one, small, hand-held device? Will that area be dominated by cell-phone companies or computer companies?
Apple – a computer company – has already entered the fray with their iPhone and caused a level of consternation.
Who’s next? HP? IBM? Acer? Lenovo?
So how should Nokia and Ericsson, Samsung and LG react – both in product terms and as brands? As of now, cell-phone brands seem to ignoring the environmental threat of convergence as brands, concentrating on entertainment and fashion instead of converging technologies. This is despite the fact that all these companies have access to the same technology as Apple.
Another example is of passenger liner brands. It took them almost fifty years to adjust to the idea that a ship is no longer an acceptable means of transport – it is just too slow. The passenger liner brands of today are entertainment brands – but it took the death of several passenger liner brands and the grounding of several ships before Royal Norwegian sailed into profitability.
Making sure a brand incorporates the ability to adapt to the changes in its environment, will inevitably lead to a stronger and less vulnerable brand.
Should a brand incorporate the consumer’s point of view?
Of course.
No question about it.
Should a brand incorporate a reaction to the competition – be competitive, in other words?
Undoubtedly.
However, the opinion of your consumer – who may or may not be your wife – is only one factor among many to be considered.
Friday, November 12, 2010
Building a Mall as a brand
In “Field of Dreams”, Kevin Costner’s character, an impoverished farmer, is pushed by some supernatural force to build a baseball diamond in the middle of his fields.
Despite the fact that his farm is in the middle of nowhere, a voice tells him, “Build it and they will come.”
At the end of the movie we see a long queue of cars approaching the field.
Most mall builders today seem to have that same somewhat untenable belief, “Build it and they will come.”
The scenario is predictable: a builder finds a nice plot of land near a good neighborhood, a college or some ‘electronic city’ and assumes that the location is perfect for a mall. The conviction is based almost entirely on gut feel and a vague idea that there are lots of youngsters from colleges/BPOs/IT companies in the area who are generally ‘well-paid’ and will therefore have cash to spend.
There are certain set architectural patterns for all malls, generally from the USA, so a developer only has to choose one and then the engineering team gets on the job. Then, within a reasonable amount of time a steel and concrete monolith rises.
Simultaneously, the developer’s marketing team is on the job. So offers are sent for space to the usual suspects: Nike, Levis, Reebok, McDonald’s, Subway, Westside, Shoppers Stop, Barista . . .
And before long a mall opens. It will have a beautifully decorated foyer in glass and marble, many glittering stores, with the smells of various delicious foods floating through the air.
It will be a mall that’s all things to all people, so it can be expected to pull in the crowds and generate revenues for all the mall’s tenants.
Unfortunately, there are five builders – all of whom have had the same idea and have bought property in the vicinity. So there are five malls clustered around a small locality. All the malls have the same or similar brands – one may have Reebok, the other Nike – all the malls have a food court, all the malls have a movie theatre.
So all around your mall are five others all of which are all things to all people.
And you’ll find you’ve built it, but . . . they’re not coming.
And there’s a reason for that.
Your mall is not a brand.
Branding a Mall
Building a mall brand cannot begin after you’ve found some land and built a swank, steel, concrete and glass structure.
It must begin well before that.
To begin with you must accept one immutable fact: a mall is not a building – it is a product.
And a product will never be accepted or purchased by a customer regularly unless and until it’s a brand.
What is a brand?
It’s the most valuable piece of real estate in the world: a part of your consumer’s mind. To amplify on that: a brand is that portion of a person’s mind, which justifies using a product repeatedly, paying a premium for it and attributing to it qualities over and above those of another product in the same category.
How can a mall become a brand?
A mall has several qualities that make it different from any other brand. To begin with it is an immovable product, but it is also a highly perishable product. So, if you have no visitors on a day, the day’s dead and gone.
Further, a mall brand is actually an experience. Every time a consumer walks into the mall her visit reinforces and strengthens the brand – and everything about the mall affects that experience; the shops, the ambience, the parking availability, the loudspeaker system, the movies, the food court . . . everything.
In short, a mall as a product and a brand is the sum of many, many parts.
You may have well-trained personnel manning the enquiry counters and the security at your mall.
However, if the sales people in one of the shops in your mall are less than polite, your entire mall brand gets affected.
Everything has to work in a mall – the air-conditioning, the food court, the escalators, the elevators, the parking arrangements, the public address system, even the stocking pattern in the stores . . . everything.
And a mall brand has to work from day one because the financial clock starts ticking then.
To make that happen you must treat it the way you would do any brand.
Designing a Mall brand
The first step would be to identify your customers and your catchment area. What kind of people do you think the mall should attract? And where are they going to be coming from?
Once you’ve made sure of the catchment area around your mall and identified your target customers, the next step is to design your brand that will attract those customers to your mall in preference to any others.
It’s all about decisions that can only come from understanding your consumers.
Do your preferred customers like large, expansive, impersonal public spaces? Or small, intimate, personalized areas?
Are they gourmets? Gourmands? Or greedy?
Do they have cars? Motorcycles? Or do they use public transport?
Are they the Marks & Spencer type? Or the Shoppers Stop type? Or the Big Bazaar type?
What will they do once they come to the mall?
Hang out?
Hang out and then watch a movie?
Hang out, watch a movie and then go to the food court?
Hang out and shop?
Do you want a movie theatre in your mall at all? There are dangers in that.
The Hidden Dangers of Movie Theatres
A small research conducted by some management students on the behalf of my old company revealed that the average expenditure at premium mall in Bangalore was only Rs.200. This meant that most people came to watch a movie and possibly grab a bite at the food court. A good percentage just came to hang out and only a small percentage actually went and shopped at the expensive stores in the mall.
A movie theatre may be a good way to attract crowds to a mall, but it is also a hugely dangerous feature.
If you have a movie theatre in your mall, people come to there and occupy your parking area for two or three hours at a time, generating no revenue for your tenants. In fact, they are creating no revenue for the mall beyond the Rs.250 for the movie tickets and the Rs.50 parking fee.
Rs.300 for three hours spent at the mall – devastating.
Further, moviegoers will prevent possible shoppers from coming into your mall. It must be remembered that there is generally no parking in the neighborhoods around a mall and if all your parking is occupied by moviegoers, shoppers – the revenue generators – will not be able to come even if they wanted to.
So the question you need to answer is, should you have a few, high-revenue customers or many low or no-revenue customers?
You might find that a great location for highly prestigious mall brand might not be able to attract any customers for a middle-market mall brand.
In sum, you have to identify your mall brand’s value propositions.
Identifying your mall’s value propositions
There are decisions that need to be taken. Will your mall brand have a functional proposition? Will it be the place to go to for cheaper stuff, more expensive stuff, sports equipment, food or diamonds and gold?
Will it possess an emotional value proposition? Will visiting your mall make people feel warmer, happier, more practical, more sensible, more sophisticated or more down-to-earth?
Will it have a self-expressive proposition? Will I become a smarter person, a more discriminating person, a more knowledgeable person or a more sensible person by visiting the mall?
These are all decisions that must be taken.
In short, you must first design your brand.
What Comes Next
It is only once the brand decisions are made that you should brief your architect, your interior designer and the landscape people. Now the design of the mall will be focused; now the building – a product – can be designed in a way that is consonant with your brand’s values and your customers’ aspirations and needs.
So, now that you know what kind of target audience you’re targeting, you can tell your architect how you want your mall designed. For example you may want a drive-in portico so that a customer can either be dropped off by her chauffeur, or leave her car for valet parking. Alternatively you may want a place where youngsters are comfortable, so you’ll have more place for parking two-wheelers.
Then, when your customer enters, what will she see?
Again, your brand identity dictates that.
Should your customers be greeted by wood and plush carpeting? Should they step into an atmosphere of gleaming chrome and glass? Should the décor include beanbags and balloons? Or should it consist of champagne glasses and leather armchairs?
Then, because every experience of the brand will communicate its values, you need to make sure the building is, in turn, populated by brands that communicate the right message by their very existence.
You cannot have a Cartier in a mall that’s targeting parents with children.
You cannot have a McDonald’s cheek-and-jowl with Omega, Rolex, Dior and Rolls-Royce . . . not because you physically cannot, but because brand logic goes against the idea.
Undoubtedly, once the brand managers see what kind of mall brand you are trying to create, they will be able to decide whether or not they want to be in your mall. And if you’ve created an appropriate brand which will match the target audience and catchment area of your mall, you won’t need to hunt for brands – they will instantly see the relevance of being in your mall.
Bringing People into your Mall
With any brand and particularly a mall brand, even if you’ve been careful to build it to match your target audience and peopled it with stores that bolster the imagery that will appeal to your target audience, the ‘build it and they will come’ philosophy does not work. You still need to publicize the brand.
Too often a large hoarding stating that a mall is coming up behind it is thought to be sufficient, when in fact, it is not.
If the mall is targeted at a particular target audience, there is obviously a good reason to address that audience with carefully designed marketing activities.
When a new casino is being built in Las Vegas – where every casino is a brand – high-rollers and high-end customers are kept informed throughout the process.
They are given sneak previews, they are invited for events when the casino is still a building site, multi-media presentations are handed out and lavish brochures and mailers are created before the casino is even built. This goes on until the point when everybody is dying for an invitation to the exclusive soft launch.
Most of all, the casino is hyped as the most lavish, the most extravagant, the most incredible casino in Las Vegas – at least until the next one comes up.
The idea is the same one every mall owner must have – to have a crowd walk n on the first day. Even if it is just to see what the hype was all about.
For a mall, pretty much the same process would be ideal. Pre-launch hype followed by an exclusive soft launch to which everybody is dying to be invited and finally the grand launch itself.
What you would do to attract the crowds would depend on the kind of crowd you plan to attract.
One target audience might demand a grand magic show by some high-end magician who makes the entire mall disappear and re-appear.
Another group of people might be more entertained by a very sophisticated cocktail party held on the construction site.
Yet another class of society might be sophisticated enough to warrant staging a Shakespearean play in the atrium.
Another group might only be enthused by a group of VJs from Channel V or MTV while another group might merit a fashion show and so on.
Marketing Existing Malls
Of course malls that have already been built still require marketing support. And the process is more or less the same.
First, identify your catchment area and therefore your target audience.
Then figure out what kind of value proposition your mall brand can offer them.
Finally, publicize that value proposition.
The activities you would use to publicize the value proposition would naturally be quite different. However, the same principles would apply.
However it’s important to understand that the promotional activities undertaken inside the mall should be calculated to add depth and dimension to the mall brand – not merely to the brand advertised.
For example, one mall in Bangalore consistently has promotional activities for various products in its atrium. These activities involve loud amplified voices, dancing, consumer contests, bad singing and huge crowds watching on every floor.
The question is, does the mall want to be seen as a constant, unrelenting mela?
Does the mela help the stores in the same mall to sell product?
Has anybody analyzed whether these promotional activities actually help the rent-paying tenants of the mall?
A good customer retention and management campaign for the mall could be part of its activities. A mall’s parking attendants could hand out membership invitations to anybody who uses a bill to defray her parking ticket – that way you know you’re developing a relationship with a person who has spent a reasonably large sum of money in your mall.
In sum, before marketing a mall, a developer has to mentally attune himself to the idea that a mall is for more than just a building.
It is a product.
And a product will not sell until it is a brand.
So a mall must use a scientific, well-designed process to become a brand.
Quod erat demonstratum.
Despite the fact that his farm is in the middle of nowhere, a voice tells him, “Build it and they will come.”
At the end of the movie we see a long queue of cars approaching the field.
Most mall builders today seem to have that same somewhat untenable belief, “Build it and they will come.”
The scenario is predictable: a builder finds a nice plot of land near a good neighborhood, a college or some ‘electronic city’ and assumes that the location is perfect for a mall. The conviction is based almost entirely on gut feel and a vague idea that there are lots of youngsters from colleges/BPOs/IT companies in the area who are generally ‘well-paid’ and will therefore have cash to spend.
There are certain set architectural patterns for all malls, generally from the USA, so a developer only has to choose one and then the engineering team gets on the job. Then, within a reasonable amount of time a steel and concrete monolith rises.
Simultaneously, the developer’s marketing team is on the job. So offers are sent for space to the usual suspects: Nike, Levis, Reebok, McDonald’s, Subway, Westside, Shoppers Stop, Barista . . .
And before long a mall opens. It will have a beautifully decorated foyer in glass and marble, many glittering stores, with the smells of various delicious foods floating through the air.
It will be a mall that’s all things to all people, so it can be expected to pull in the crowds and generate revenues for all the mall’s tenants.
Unfortunately, there are five builders – all of whom have had the same idea and have bought property in the vicinity. So there are five malls clustered around a small locality. All the malls have the same or similar brands – one may have Reebok, the other Nike – all the malls have a food court, all the malls have a movie theatre.
So all around your mall are five others all of which are all things to all people.
And you’ll find you’ve built it, but . . . they’re not coming.
And there’s a reason for that.
Your mall is not a brand.
Branding a Mall
Building a mall brand cannot begin after you’ve found some land and built a swank, steel, concrete and glass structure.
It must begin well before that.
To begin with you must accept one immutable fact: a mall is not a building – it is a product.
And a product will never be accepted or purchased by a customer regularly unless and until it’s a brand.
What is a brand?
It’s the most valuable piece of real estate in the world: a part of your consumer’s mind. To amplify on that: a brand is that portion of a person’s mind, which justifies using a product repeatedly, paying a premium for it and attributing to it qualities over and above those of another product in the same category.
How can a mall become a brand?
A mall has several qualities that make it different from any other brand. To begin with it is an immovable product, but it is also a highly perishable product. So, if you have no visitors on a day, the day’s dead and gone.
Further, a mall brand is actually an experience. Every time a consumer walks into the mall her visit reinforces and strengthens the brand – and everything about the mall affects that experience; the shops, the ambience, the parking availability, the loudspeaker system, the movies, the food court . . . everything.
In short, a mall as a product and a brand is the sum of many, many parts.
You may have well-trained personnel manning the enquiry counters and the security at your mall.
However, if the sales people in one of the shops in your mall are less than polite, your entire mall brand gets affected.
Everything has to work in a mall – the air-conditioning, the food court, the escalators, the elevators, the parking arrangements, the public address system, even the stocking pattern in the stores . . . everything.
And a mall brand has to work from day one because the financial clock starts ticking then.
To make that happen you must treat it the way you would do any brand.
Designing a Mall brand
The first step would be to identify your customers and your catchment area. What kind of people do you think the mall should attract? And where are they going to be coming from?
Once you’ve made sure of the catchment area around your mall and identified your target customers, the next step is to design your brand that will attract those customers to your mall in preference to any others.
It’s all about decisions that can only come from understanding your consumers.
Do your preferred customers like large, expansive, impersonal public spaces? Or small, intimate, personalized areas?
Are they gourmets? Gourmands? Or greedy?
Do they have cars? Motorcycles? Or do they use public transport?
Are they the Marks & Spencer type? Or the Shoppers Stop type? Or the Big Bazaar type?
What will they do once they come to the mall?
Hang out?
Hang out and then watch a movie?
Hang out, watch a movie and then go to the food court?
Hang out and shop?
Do you want a movie theatre in your mall at all? There are dangers in that.
The Hidden Dangers of Movie Theatres
A small research conducted by some management students on the behalf of my old company revealed that the average expenditure at premium mall in Bangalore was only Rs.200. This meant that most people came to watch a movie and possibly grab a bite at the food court. A good percentage just came to hang out and only a small percentage actually went and shopped at the expensive stores in the mall.
A movie theatre may be a good way to attract crowds to a mall, but it is also a hugely dangerous feature.
If you have a movie theatre in your mall, people come to there and occupy your parking area for two or three hours at a time, generating no revenue for your tenants. In fact, they are creating no revenue for the mall beyond the Rs.250 for the movie tickets and the Rs.50 parking fee.
Rs.300 for three hours spent at the mall – devastating.
Further, moviegoers will prevent possible shoppers from coming into your mall. It must be remembered that there is generally no parking in the neighborhoods around a mall and if all your parking is occupied by moviegoers, shoppers – the revenue generators – will not be able to come even if they wanted to.
So the question you need to answer is, should you have a few, high-revenue customers or many low or no-revenue customers?
You might find that a great location for highly prestigious mall brand might not be able to attract any customers for a middle-market mall brand.
In sum, you have to identify your mall brand’s value propositions.
Identifying your mall’s value propositions
There are decisions that need to be taken. Will your mall brand have a functional proposition? Will it be the place to go to for cheaper stuff, more expensive stuff, sports equipment, food or diamonds and gold?
Will it possess an emotional value proposition? Will visiting your mall make people feel warmer, happier, more practical, more sensible, more sophisticated or more down-to-earth?
Will it have a self-expressive proposition? Will I become a smarter person, a more discriminating person, a more knowledgeable person or a more sensible person by visiting the mall?
These are all decisions that must be taken.
In short, you must first design your brand.
What Comes Next
It is only once the brand decisions are made that you should brief your architect, your interior designer and the landscape people. Now the design of the mall will be focused; now the building – a product – can be designed in a way that is consonant with your brand’s values and your customers’ aspirations and needs.
So, now that you know what kind of target audience you’re targeting, you can tell your architect how you want your mall designed. For example you may want a drive-in portico so that a customer can either be dropped off by her chauffeur, or leave her car for valet parking. Alternatively you may want a place where youngsters are comfortable, so you’ll have more place for parking two-wheelers.
Then, when your customer enters, what will she see?
Again, your brand identity dictates that.
Should your customers be greeted by wood and plush carpeting? Should they step into an atmosphere of gleaming chrome and glass? Should the décor include beanbags and balloons? Or should it consist of champagne glasses and leather armchairs?
Then, because every experience of the brand will communicate its values, you need to make sure the building is, in turn, populated by brands that communicate the right message by their very existence.
You cannot have a Cartier in a mall that’s targeting parents with children.
You cannot have a McDonald’s cheek-and-jowl with Omega, Rolex, Dior and Rolls-Royce . . . not because you physically cannot, but because brand logic goes against the idea.
Undoubtedly, once the brand managers see what kind of mall brand you are trying to create, they will be able to decide whether or not they want to be in your mall. And if you’ve created an appropriate brand which will match the target audience and catchment area of your mall, you won’t need to hunt for brands – they will instantly see the relevance of being in your mall.
Bringing People into your Mall
With any brand and particularly a mall brand, even if you’ve been careful to build it to match your target audience and peopled it with stores that bolster the imagery that will appeal to your target audience, the ‘build it and they will come’ philosophy does not work. You still need to publicize the brand.
Too often a large hoarding stating that a mall is coming up behind it is thought to be sufficient, when in fact, it is not.
If the mall is targeted at a particular target audience, there is obviously a good reason to address that audience with carefully designed marketing activities.
When a new casino is being built in Las Vegas – where every casino is a brand – high-rollers and high-end customers are kept informed throughout the process.
They are given sneak previews, they are invited for events when the casino is still a building site, multi-media presentations are handed out and lavish brochures and mailers are created before the casino is even built. This goes on until the point when everybody is dying for an invitation to the exclusive soft launch.
Most of all, the casino is hyped as the most lavish, the most extravagant, the most incredible casino in Las Vegas – at least until the next one comes up.
The idea is the same one every mall owner must have – to have a crowd walk n on the first day. Even if it is just to see what the hype was all about.
For a mall, pretty much the same process would be ideal. Pre-launch hype followed by an exclusive soft launch to which everybody is dying to be invited and finally the grand launch itself.
What you would do to attract the crowds would depend on the kind of crowd you plan to attract.
One target audience might demand a grand magic show by some high-end magician who makes the entire mall disappear and re-appear.
Another group of people might be more entertained by a very sophisticated cocktail party held on the construction site.
Yet another class of society might be sophisticated enough to warrant staging a Shakespearean play in the atrium.
Another group might only be enthused by a group of VJs from Channel V or MTV while another group might merit a fashion show and so on.
Marketing Existing Malls
Of course malls that have already been built still require marketing support. And the process is more or less the same.
First, identify your catchment area and therefore your target audience.
Then figure out what kind of value proposition your mall brand can offer them.
Finally, publicize that value proposition.
The activities you would use to publicize the value proposition would naturally be quite different. However, the same principles would apply.
However it’s important to understand that the promotional activities undertaken inside the mall should be calculated to add depth and dimension to the mall brand – not merely to the brand advertised.
For example, one mall in Bangalore consistently has promotional activities for various products in its atrium. These activities involve loud amplified voices, dancing, consumer contests, bad singing and huge crowds watching on every floor.
The question is, does the mall want to be seen as a constant, unrelenting mela?
Does the mela help the stores in the same mall to sell product?
Has anybody analyzed whether these promotional activities actually help the rent-paying tenants of the mall?
A good customer retention and management campaign for the mall could be part of its activities. A mall’s parking attendants could hand out membership invitations to anybody who uses a bill to defray her parking ticket – that way you know you’re developing a relationship with a person who has spent a reasonably large sum of money in your mall.
In sum, before marketing a mall, a developer has to mentally attune himself to the idea that a mall is for more than just a building.
It is a product.
And a product will not sell until it is a brand.
So a mall must use a scientific, well-designed process to become a brand.
Quod erat demonstratum.
Brand is behavior
What is branding all about? It’s not communication. It’s not design and it’s not your logo or corporate identity.
It’s how you behave.
And remember, today, your behavior is high, wide and public – regardless of what you would like to do.
An airline’s stewardess cannot get away with being a complete bitch without the world – or at least a portion of it – knowing about it. If the person she is rude to happens to have a blog and a few thousand followers, oops, a few thousand people have a negative view of your brand.
For example, Jet Airways would be well-advised to spend less money on yellow roses and yellow uniforms and a little more time and money training their people. Their ‘branding’ and their communication is like seeing Dawood Ibrahim in an Armani suit – no matter how elegant the outfit, it doesn’t hide the essential quality of the beast.
Think of it as a person. How she dresses, how well her make-up has been laid on, or how beautifully her hair has been cut is hardly relevant if she’s a conniving, under-handed termagant. And, unfortunately, people can tell the reality of a brand instantly from its behavior – they always could – but today is different in that, they can tell everybody they know about their experience.
And they can do it almost instantaneously, within minutes or even seconds of their bad experience.
We live in a global village. The Golden Age of advertising and branding that results from pure communication is over. Now we’re going back 200 years, when a housewife asked her neighbor what was the best way to get clean flour.
I remember an essential bit of Alfred Hitchcock’s ‘Three Investigators’ books – the use of Jupiter Jones’ idea of asking five friends to ask five friends for a clue in exchange for a reward. In one book, all the lines in the town are engaged – basically because of this idea. In today’s world that is a reality - one person tells two hundred and fifty friends on Facebook, they in turn tell two hundred friends of their own (that 'share' tab is lethal) and before you know it thousands of people know about the foul experience some random stranger had with your brand.
Do you remember that letter some anonymous passenger sent to Richard Branson? I can't think of many who don't. And has that affected their view of Virgin? Hmmm . . . dumb question.
Go on to your computer and Google any product if you don’t believe me. The first few sites you’ll find will always include a site that has consumer views on all the brands in your category – not your precious website. And anyway, most people look for ‘passenger cars’ not Hyundai Santro or Maruti 800. And not all the view are complimentary.
So what can traditional branding do to counter the new consumer? What can it do to counter the speed with which bad opinions spread?
In a word, nothing.
You cannot communicate your way out of a product problem. Bill Bernbach’s view that good advertising only makes a bad product fail faster applies in spades in today’s world.
If somebody doesn’t like your product, you can more or less take for granted that his or her view is going to appear somewhere on the net. And once it’s on the net, it’s there forever, immutable – you cannot erase it.
So there’s one simple solution. Make sure Bad Things don’t happen in the first place.
It means every single person inside the company has to understand the brand and has to be free to express it. The factory worker has to be free to reject a product if it’s not up to the mark. The receptionist has to be free to do what’s right for a customer if that’s what’s required.
In today’s Global Village every company is now a service business and in a service business, the lowest paid employees are the ones who are on the front lines. They’re the ones who can make or break your brand.
So today’s branding is about training. It’s about teaching, it’s about making sure each and every employee understands what the brand is about and lives it. If Jet Airways is about service, then every employee – down to the lowest nitwit must understand that. And if he or she doesn’t understand that, she must be ushered out of the premises with great speed – because what she doesn’t understand will be communicated to Jet’s passengers.
Branding is no longer what you say – it’s what you do. It’s not just your product – it’s your entire company’s behavior.
And bad behavior usually involves some painful consequences.
It’s how you behave.
And remember, today, your behavior is high, wide and public – regardless of what you would like to do.
An airline’s stewardess cannot get away with being a complete bitch without the world – or at least a portion of it – knowing about it. If the person she is rude to happens to have a blog and a few thousand followers, oops, a few thousand people have a negative view of your brand.
For example, Jet Airways would be well-advised to spend less money on yellow roses and yellow uniforms and a little more time and money training their people. Their ‘branding’ and their communication is like seeing Dawood Ibrahim in an Armani suit – no matter how elegant the outfit, it doesn’t hide the essential quality of the beast.
Think of it as a person. How she dresses, how well her make-up has been laid on, or how beautifully her hair has been cut is hardly relevant if she’s a conniving, under-handed termagant. And, unfortunately, people can tell the reality of a brand instantly from its behavior – they always could – but today is different in that, they can tell everybody they know about their experience.
And they can do it almost instantaneously, within minutes or even seconds of their bad experience.
We live in a global village. The Golden Age of advertising and branding that results from pure communication is over. Now we’re going back 200 years, when a housewife asked her neighbor what was the best way to get clean flour.
I remember an essential bit of Alfred Hitchcock’s ‘Three Investigators’ books – the use of Jupiter Jones’ idea of asking five friends to ask five friends for a clue in exchange for a reward. In one book, all the lines in the town are engaged – basically because of this idea. In today’s world that is a reality - one person tells two hundred and fifty friends on Facebook, they in turn tell two hundred friends of their own (that 'share' tab is lethal) and before you know it thousands of people know about the foul experience some random stranger had with your brand.
Do you remember that letter some anonymous passenger sent to Richard Branson? I can't think of many who don't. And has that affected their view of Virgin? Hmmm . . . dumb question.
Go on to your computer and Google any product if you don’t believe me. The first few sites you’ll find will always include a site that has consumer views on all the brands in your category – not your precious website. And anyway, most people look for ‘passenger cars’ not Hyundai Santro or Maruti 800. And not all the view are complimentary.
So what can traditional branding do to counter the new consumer? What can it do to counter the speed with which bad opinions spread?
In a word, nothing.
You cannot communicate your way out of a product problem. Bill Bernbach’s view that good advertising only makes a bad product fail faster applies in spades in today’s world.
If somebody doesn’t like your product, you can more or less take for granted that his or her view is going to appear somewhere on the net. And once it’s on the net, it’s there forever, immutable – you cannot erase it.
So there’s one simple solution. Make sure Bad Things don’t happen in the first place.
It means every single person inside the company has to understand the brand and has to be free to express it. The factory worker has to be free to reject a product if it’s not up to the mark. The receptionist has to be free to do what’s right for a customer if that’s what’s required.
In today’s Global Village every company is now a service business and in a service business, the lowest paid employees are the ones who are on the front lines. They’re the ones who can make or break your brand.
So today’s branding is about training. It’s about teaching, it’s about making sure each and every employee understands what the brand is about and lives it. If Jet Airways is about service, then every employee – down to the lowest nitwit must understand that. And if he or she doesn’t understand that, she must be ushered out of the premises with great speed – because what she doesn’t understand will be communicated to Jet’s passengers.
Branding is no longer what you say – it’s what you do. It’s not just your product – it’s your entire company’s behavior.
And bad behavior usually involves some painful consequences.
Monday, November 08, 2010
How retail killed the garment brand
Most garment marketers know that all men have a portfolio of brands in their cupboards. They also undoubtedly know that men use different garments for different purposes.
However, their positioning and branding doesn’t seem to reflect that knowledge.
And in my view, that’s the core reason why most Indian middle-market garment brands are not really strong brands.
Instead, today, if you look at it carefully, most Indian garment brands are actually retail brands.
To understand how and why this happened, it may be necessary to look at history a bit.
Formal branded garments began with Zodiac. Park Avenue wasn’t really a garment brand – it was more of a retail brand with Raymond’s trying to use some of the space they had on hand.
Zodiac had no real brand positioning – it was just meant to represent a ‘male’ shirt with advertising showing a rather hirsute male. The same advertisement ran for years.
The game was changed drastically by Madura Garments who launched Louis Philippe and Van Heusen. Both these brands had a distinct imagery – Louis Philippe, with ‘The Upper Crest’ was very clearly for high-end, sophisticated men – the board room if you like. Van Heusen was the ‘corporate’ brand and had a clear image with first ‘underline your presence’ and then ‘power-dressing’ – Vice-Presidents and Senior Management in terms of target audience.
Madura Garments followed that up with Allen Solly, which was aimed at the more ‘artistic’ and right-brain oriented professionals – architects, designers, the ‘communications elite’. Finally, they completed their palette with Peter England, the good value corporate shirt – aimed at the lower level executives, the clerks and so on.
Okay. So all was well.
Then, Madura Garments, the biggest player got bitten by the retail bug. So, Allen Solly, Louis Philippe and Van Heusen were sold together under the roof of Planet Fashion. All the brands were clubbed together in one environment. Naturally, the distinctions between the retail spaces of the brands were blurred.
But what followed should have been preceded by huge red signals from the concerned parties; the only branding devices left – the actual garments and the advertising – became blurred.
Every shirt brand seemed to be willing to use some fancy international location and international models – the earlier differentiation between the brands was slowly, but inevitably eroded.
Then came the entire problem of stock clearance. A boon to every red-blooded, Indian male who so fervently believes a penny saved is a penny earned. The thinking was simple, ‘Anyway, I’m not picky about which brand I wear – so I’ll buy the shirt that’s on sale or at the Factory Price Store closest to me.’
The net result is that today, there is no difference between any of the brands, barring, possibly Louis Philippe. Instead the consumer is faced with a glorious, undifferentiated blur. So, you’ve no reason to relate any brand to any time, usage, personality, philosophy or way of life.
You just go out to buy ‘a shirt’ – any shirt, for any purpose. Whereas earlier, you might have insisted on wearing an Allen Solly if you’re in the creative department of an advertising agency, today, you could equally well go with a Louis Philippe, a Van Heusen, an Indigo Nation, a Scullers or even a Peter England.
It makes no difference.
This sounds good to the factory manager and warehouse keeper, but should make no sense to a marketer.
So what’s the solution?
In my belief, if they want to sell more garments, manufacturers need to stop chasing the dream of the ‘retail revolution’ and return to the basics of sharply differentiated targeting and branding to those targets.
And the weird part of it is that this is not difficult to do.
In my belief, brand is behavior. It's not communication.
So, the first step would be look at your product portfolio. The decisions are basically governed by which product belongs to which brand.
A red, brushed-silk shirt should go to Allen Solly or Scullers, regardless of how expensive it is. A clean crisp white cotton shirt goes to Louis Philippe or Indigo Nation, a blue pin-stripe goes into Van Heusen. The plain, inexpensive fabrics and cuts should go to John Miller and Peter England.
You won’t get a bright red Van Heusen, just as you won’t get staid, sober and corporate in Allen Solly.
The next step would be to differentiate the retail environment in which each brand is sold. Carefully decide the colors, the flooring, the scent in the air, the music, even the kind of salesmen and what they wear.
Finally, you need focused communication.
Obviously this starts with preferably well-written advertising – as opposed to well photographed and well art-directed advertising. This would be bolstered by events and sponsorships that make sense for each brand. For example, it would make sense for Van Heusen to be a part of corporate training programs and seminars, Louis Philippe to be around corporate golf events and for Allen Solly to be essential at music and cultural happenings.
Of course, these are only a few of the possible existing positioning routes possible – there are many more. But it would require a scientific process and a carefully-thought-out brand design. But it can be done.
The question is, do garment manufacturers and their professional managers know this?
Awkward question, that.
However, their positioning and branding doesn’t seem to reflect that knowledge.
And in my view, that’s the core reason why most Indian middle-market garment brands are not really strong brands.
Instead, today, if you look at it carefully, most Indian garment brands are actually retail brands.
To understand how and why this happened, it may be necessary to look at history a bit.
Formal branded garments began with Zodiac. Park Avenue wasn’t really a garment brand – it was more of a retail brand with Raymond’s trying to use some of the space they had on hand.
Zodiac had no real brand positioning – it was just meant to represent a ‘male’ shirt with advertising showing a rather hirsute male. The same advertisement ran for years.
The game was changed drastically by Madura Garments who launched Louis Philippe and Van Heusen. Both these brands had a distinct imagery – Louis Philippe, with ‘The Upper Crest’ was very clearly for high-end, sophisticated men – the board room if you like. Van Heusen was the ‘corporate’ brand and had a clear image with first ‘underline your presence’ and then ‘power-dressing’ – Vice-Presidents and Senior Management in terms of target audience.
Madura Garments followed that up with Allen Solly, which was aimed at the more ‘artistic’ and right-brain oriented professionals – architects, designers, the ‘communications elite’. Finally, they completed their palette with Peter England, the good value corporate shirt – aimed at the lower level executives, the clerks and so on.
Okay. So all was well.
Then, Madura Garments, the biggest player got bitten by the retail bug. So, Allen Solly, Louis Philippe and Van Heusen were sold together under the roof of Planet Fashion. All the brands were clubbed together in one environment. Naturally, the distinctions between the retail spaces of the brands were blurred.
But what followed should have been preceded by huge red signals from the concerned parties; the only branding devices left – the actual garments and the advertising – became blurred.
Every shirt brand seemed to be willing to use some fancy international location and international models – the earlier differentiation between the brands was slowly, but inevitably eroded.
Then came the entire problem of stock clearance. A boon to every red-blooded, Indian male who so fervently believes a penny saved is a penny earned. The thinking was simple, ‘Anyway, I’m not picky about which brand I wear – so I’ll buy the shirt that’s on sale or at the Factory Price Store closest to me.’
The net result is that today, there is no difference between any of the brands, barring, possibly Louis Philippe. Instead the consumer is faced with a glorious, undifferentiated blur. So, you’ve no reason to relate any brand to any time, usage, personality, philosophy or way of life.
You just go out to buy ‘a shirt’ – any shirt, for any purpose. Whereas earlier, you might have insisted on wearing an Allen Solly if you’re in the creative department of an advertising agency, today, you could equally well go with a Louis Philippe, a Van Heusen, an Indigo Nation, a Scullers or even a Peter England.
It makes no difference.
This sounds good to the factory manager and warehouse keeper, but should make no sense to a marketer.
So what’s the solution?
In my belief, if they want to sell more garments, manufacturers need to stop chasing the dream of the ‘retail revolution’ and return to the basics of sharply differentiated targeting and branding to those targets.
And the weird part of it is that this is not difficult to do.
In my belief, brand is behavior. It's not communication.
So, the first step would be look at your product portfolio. The decisions are basically governed by which product belongs to which brand.
A red, brushed-silk shirt should go to Allen Solly or Scullers, regardless of how expensive it is. A clean crisp white cotton shirt goes to Louis Philippe or Indigo Nation, a blue pin-stripe goes into Van Heusen. The plain, inexpensive fabrics and cuts should go to John Miller and Peter England.
You won’t get a bright red Van Heusen, just as you won’t get staid, sober and corporate in Allen Solly.
The next step would be to differentiate the retail environment in which each brand is sold. Carefully decide the colors, the flooring, the scent in the air, the music, even the kind of salesmen and what they wear.
Finally, you need focused communication.
Obviously this starts with preferably well-written advertising – as opposed to well photographed and well art-directed advertising. This would be bolstered by events and sponsorships that make sense for each brand. For example, it would make sense for Van Heusen to be a part of corporate training programs and seminars, Louis Philippe to be around corporate golf events and for Allen Solly to be essential at music and cultural happenings.
Of course, these are only a few of the possible existing positioning routes possible – there are many more. But it would require a scientific process and a carefully-thought-out brand design. But it can be done.
The question is, do garment manufacturers and their professional managers know this?
Awkward question, that.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)