Sunday, October 17, 2010

Branding in the Digital Era

Anybody who is seriously looking at branding in the digital era cannot afford to ignore two players: Google and the porn industry.Google has been the subject of enough study to fill a large encyclopaedia. The porn industry is, however, ignored as being below contempt.

This may be a mistake. After all, the porn industry is enormous. TopTenREVIEWS, Internet publisher of expert product reviews for software and web services, released the newest statistics on the porn industry. 

Size of Porn Industry -  $57 Billion world wide

Internet Porn -     $2.5 Billion

Child Pornography -    $3.0 Billion

US porn revenue exceeds the combined revenues of ABC, CBS, and NBC (6.2 billion)

Child pornography generates $3 billion annually

Pornography revenue is larger than all combined revenues of all profession football, baseball and basketball franchise

There are 4.2 million Pornographic websites.  (12% of Internet)

Average age of first exposure to Internet Pornography is 5 years

Largest Consumer of Internet pornography is the 12-17 age group

There are 100,000 websites offering illegal Child Pornography

90% of  8 - 16 year olds have seen pornography on the Internet

29% of 7 -17 year olds freely give out their home address

In short, branding and marketing in the digital era is dominated by the porn industry and my belief is that this is so because the porn industry shows an understanding of the media that seems to be missing among mainline marketers.

So spend a moment to analyze the nature of the internet.

If you take its genesis, it was developed to be and now is, essentially, a collaborative media. It was developed through the efforts of thousands of software developers, scientists and amateurs. Not just the content – the media itself. Which means, to use it appropriately, collaboration is essential.

Secondly, it is a connective media. Meaning that one piece of knowledge leads to another which leads to a third until you have all the dots connected.

Third it is in many ways an involuntary media. You voluntarily switch on your television, pick up a newspaper or magazine, but on the internet, pieces of mail, publicity material, pop-ups and so on land up on your desk-top without so much as a by-your-leave.

Fourth and this is the paradox of the digital era, it is also a voluntary media. For many of us, www meant the world-wide wait, but we clicked on the icon and waited and then clicked on a site and waited and then clicked on a link and waited.

We cursed, fumed and moaned through it all.

But we did it.

And we’re still doing it – voluntarily.

The fact is we want the information and the products that we can pull off the web.

Fifth, it is a responsive media. The internet is a two-way relationship. Today, you talk to the consumer and even the most unregenerate luddite has the ability to respond – without much technical knowledge. And if you do not respond to every person’s concerns word will spread. There is an old saying, “When somebody likes something he tells his six best friends, when he hates it he tells one thousand acquaintances.” This applies in spades on the net.

Finally, it is a literary media. People hit the net expecting to read and most of the pornographic sites seem to understand this, although of course, their writing abilities are strictly limited.

This acute understanding of the media in which they operate seems to be a key factor in the way the porn industry approaches branding. Of course, this in addition to a product that 50% of humanity intensely desires!

It starts with the universal understanding that human beings love anything free – even though we all understand that you cannot get something for nothing.

So the porn industry is always ready to offer you something free – there are a host of sites that purport to offer you free pictures and films of any sort of sexual activity you would care to name – and they deliver.

These sites have no physical equivalent. The key difference is that you don’t buy anything there, instead, if you click on any one of the links that are on these sites, they take you straight to a pay site. At the pay site you can download trailers, snippets and photographs of various kinds of sexual activity – free.

In short, these sites help you sample a variety of goods – they also give reviews (reviews!) of various pornographic sites, brands and products and links to the sites of those brands that have been reviewed.

In short, they deliver with teasers, flirtation and trailers of the goodies to come – in common marketing parlance, that’s called sampling. Of course, for every click-through that converts into a sale, the so-called ‘free’ sampling site gets a commission.
Then when you move into the sites, you discover something interesting – all the sites with similar ‘branding’ are hooked up, even collaborative. Take a membership of one you’ll get membership of a number of others – all similar brands. And there are pornographic brands: those with professional actors, those with amateurs, those with hand-held cameras; those with glossy, great production quality; those with specific sexual activity. All these are clearly classified and understood and all are connected.
What’s interesting is the way in which these brands communicate their product – there are phrases which every punter understands – MILF, for example means “Mothers I’d Like to ****.” This generally refers to younger men chasing older women and there are brands that advertise this as their key brand deliverable. Ditto lesbianism, homosexuality, animalism etcetera, etcetera.

What’s interesting to note is that it is very clear what is on offer.

Of course, the involuntary bit is also taken up by pornographic sites with a vengeance. So if you visit one of them – and you won’t do it by mistake – you’ll be bombarded by mail with pornographic images, with advertisements for other sites. Further, if you have switched off your pop-up protection, when you visit the initial ‘sample’ site, you’ll have a hundred different, similar sites opening up on your desktop.

This can be extremely embarrassing when you’re doing the research for an article like this – just kidding.

In short, the beginning of branding in the porn industry is the plethora of ‘free’ sites that direct consumers to the particular brand they desire. You then connect to a brand that offers the kind of product you’re looking for.
The key point is that everybody gets paid.

In the regular digital branding space there is no equivalent to the porn industry – which is incidentally reputed to be the most profitable user of e-selling.

Instead, companies scramble for space on the internet, competing with each other, treating it like any other media.
So how will the era of digital branding pan out?

I believe that companies will have to start taking it seriously – as seriously as the porn industry – which means they will have to begin by understanding the nature of the media.

Look at the way it is today.

While writing this, I Googled ‘cell phones’ and the first site that popped up is something called infibeam.com. There are tons of cell phones from various manufacturers on the site and it is a selling site so below each cell phone there are prices.

And nothing else.

Not one word of salesmanship, not an iota of a description of the product. Nothing. Zero. Nada.

Now Google up something pornographic on the net – for example ‘lesbian porn’ – and what do you get?

“Free Porn - Free Porn Clips - Free Lesbian Videos - Lesbian Porn ...”

Followed by a line that says, “Home for the best free Lesbian Videos, updated daily.

As David Ogilvy once wrote, “The soul of an advertisement is promise, great promise.” And I can’t see a bigger promise than that!

Take the cell phone site on the other hand, it reads, “InfiBeam - Online Shopping India - Buy New/ Used Mobile Phones ...” Then it goes on with a line below, “Infibeam.com launches Books! 15,00000 books, consistently low prices. Buy and have it shipped for Free! Cars · Buy New Car · Buy Used Car ...” in other words, anything and everything.

Incompetent salesmanship apart from everything else.

Branding in the digital era has to move towards a more collaborative model. To continue with the example, over time, cell phone manufacturers need to get together and appear on a single website that will direct consumers to their various websites, while the original host gets a commission on every click through – this will encourage websites to write better copy for each cell phone apart from everything else.

There are just too many sites out there and to expect a consumer to trawl through each manufacturers’ site is just expecting too much, since you can google up over 1,00,000 sites for any single request.

So each brand will have to own a single, very focused position.

How would that translate for a cell phone site?

All the cell phone brands would appear on a single site.

The site wouldn’t sell you anything – instead it would direct you to each company’s website through some enticing combination of freebies and sampling of some sort. But involved in that is that every brand has a very clear positioning that appeals to some consumer mind-set or other. So the click-throughs will happen.

Once your consumer hits your site the brand needs to pull him in with all the gimmicks they can manage – pop-ups, free offers and everything else the marketing department can conjure up.

In sum, branding in the digital era is going to be about using the properties of the internet.

It’s going to be about focus and dispersion; about increased collaboration co-existing with competition; finally it’s going to be about using the voluntary and involuntary properties of the net.

By focus, I mean each brand will have to own a very thinly sliced niche – at least on the web. For example, there will be ‘music’ phones and ‘information’ phones. Although the music phones may have the capability to store information, they won’t be part of their promise. Ditto the information phones. And the niches may get even thinner – for example, rock ‘n’ roll phones versus rap phones.

This will make co-existing with the competition easier because then the owners of various, competing brands will be able to co-exist on various convergence sites – sites that don’t sell anything, but guide punters to your site.

When you talk about increasing collaboration, I mean for example that a high-end cell-phone brand will have links to a low-end one, or a cell phone that specializes in music ‘phones will have links to sites that specialize in ‘information’ ‘phones.

This is, of course, hypothetical, however what is certain is that all the users of the digital media – the net – will have to get used to the idiosyncrasies of the medium, just as in the eighties, Indian advertisers had to get used to the idiosyncrasies of the medium called television. The only difference is that while in the eighties we had the experience of the US and Europe to learn from, today we’re learning at the same time as the rest of the world. We can’t learn from others’ mistakes.

Branding in the digital era? It’s going to be a walk into the Wild West.

Experience Brands

Hotels, restaurants, shops, airlines, malls, cruise ships, hospitals . . . services like these represent the most exciting opportunity in branding. Complicated and simple, easy and difficult, branding a consumer service is going to be the marketing challenge of the next 10 years.

Unfortunately, in most cases – barring a few honourable exceptions – a consumer services brand is marketed like any fast-moving consumer good.

In other words, with advertising and other forms of communication, promotions and PR – all of which adds up to a purely external, cosmetic form of branding.

The reason for this is because we’re ignoring the basic character of a consumer services product, which unlike an FMCG immediately involves all 5 senses.

Think of the way in which a person experiences a consumer services product – a mall for example.
First, she may see an advertisement for a movie or a sale. If the advertisement is on television, it’ll engage her sense of sight and sound, otherwise it’s just her eyes.

But when she enters the mall . . . how her world changes!

She is simultaneously assaulted at every level.

To illustrate, imagine that she is struck deaf for the first 30 seconds. So how will she experience the mall?

Through her eyes – and what a lot there is to see!

Her head will be swivelling around, left to right, up and down, taking in the flashing lights, the ‘SALE!’ signs the uniforms, the glistening escalator, the glass lifts, the beautifully lit windows, full of jewellery, clothes, shoes, food, cosmetics, sports goods and any number of other enticing products.

Thousands of brands will be screaming out their names – Nike! Reebok! Adidas! Levi’s! Wrangler! McDonald’s! Pizza Hut! Shoppers Stop! Rolex! Omega!

Simultaneously she will be looking at the people around her – young, old, short, tall, she sees older women in their kanjeevarams or swank salwars, the teeny-boppers in their tight jeans and skimpy tops, the young studs with their biceps bulging, the older men with their bush shirts hanging out of the trousers, she’ll see people from every corner of the country from the pretty, fashionable, young things from the North-East to the more conservative young ladies of Chennai to the stylish Delhi girls.

Then suddenly, her sense of hearing kicks in and she starts hearing things – music, announcements, people talking in the many languages of India, the clatter of the escalators, the hum of the elevators, the staccato tapping of high heels on the linoleum . . .

With it, comes her sense of smell and she inhales a mix of various scents that have been sprayed, biscuits baking, the smell of fresh corn or popcorn, the smell of new leather, new clothes, floor cleaning fluid, sweat, dirt and in many cases, urine.

Under her feet, she can feel the difference in the hardness of the floor or the softness of carpeting

Then, possibly, she’ll enter the food court and she’ll get a taste of the mall – which could be anything that she chooses. Of course, she may have already been tempted by the smell of the biscuits or the corn or popcorn and sampled some.
But, in essence, all her senses have been engaged, which is exciting, interesting and what makes the whole experience so vivid and so different that she wants an encore on a reasonably regular basis.

But has the mall done anything that will actually ensure that she will definitely return or done anything to make any of those experiences memorable?

Absolutely not.

Take a trip to another experience brand on the other hand – a church.

When you walk in you hear the sounds of either prayer, bells or if you’re lucky a choir practicing, but the sounds are low, reverential.

While you stand around, you smell the scent of incense, a faint aroma of wine and burning candles.

Then you walk in and see sights that communicate the one point program that they have – to sell the idea of Jesus, Mother Mary and the Saints – through stained glass window, icons, statues, the memorials to long-dead people, the huge, awe-inspiring organ, glowing in that dim, dense light. At the same time, you take in the altar, the pews, the old, polished wood and the tattered, well-thumbed prayer books.

Then you feel the graves through your shoes, you sense the rough stone, you sit on the smooth, old wood – and hear it creak.

Then the service starts. And you hear the priest’s voice echoing through that space, the voices of the faithful and their amens and their chorus with their prayers.

You taste the wine and the bread, you smell the incense.

It’s all calculated to engage each and every sense to connect you intimately to the brand, Christianity.

Your experience of the Christianity brand is a dictated experience and the experience doesn’t change much over the world. It’s the same in church after church, whether it’s a small chapel in Ootacamund or a grand cathedral in Chartres.

On the other hand, there is no effort to dictate the experience in most retail brands.

One exception is Kingfisher Airlines which has gone partially down that road. The ladies in red, the idea of calling passengers ‘guests’, the red suitcases, even the visual and emotional buttons like Dr. Mallya’s welcome speech . . . but could they do more?

Could they have a different smell in their aircraft? A specially developed air freshener which hints at beer perhaps?

Could they serve non-alcoholic beer along with the other cold drinks – an element of specific and immediately identifiable taste?

What more could they do to brand Kingfisher Airlines irretrievably, irrevocably and completely?

How could they brand the food?

The decor?

The feel of the planes?

And how can they do this while simultaneously expressing the brand identity?

That is the interesting part – the challenge – how do you match the various sensory experiences with your brand’s values?
With Kingfisher it may be relatively easy, but how about a mall, a hospital or a hotel? How do you make each of those unique, and inimitable?

That’s the challenge – to give an experience brand a position and make sure that each consumer contact point reflects that position.

So should you handle your service brand?

A sensible process would involve an extensive research and analysis of your brand, its consumers, your internal strengths and weaknesses, the environment which would lead us to an appropriate brand identity.

Then you should analyze the consumer touch points that affect your brand and your business and try to understand their relative importance in light of the brand identity.

Finally, you should engineer each touch point so that each consumer interaction will reinforce the brand identity.

Take an example of how you might do that in the case of a luxury mall – where your brand positioning is summed up by the word, ‘luxury’.

When your consumer enters, she is greeted by a quiet, discreet, hushed atmosphere; there is only the tinkle of Western classical music, no loud announcements because there is some kind of sound-damping equipment in the floors and walls that absorbs sound. The escalators and elevators seem to move more quietly and discreetly.

Even the people in the mall seem to be the quiet, sophisticated type, who would understand the difference between Chanel and Paco Rabanne, Armani and Marks & Spencer, Axe and Jovan, a Chablis and a Burgundy, a Meerschaum and a briar or a Brioni and an Armani.

The brands you see reflect the customers, there is no Titan or Timex instead you’ll see Rolex, no Sansui or Sony, but definitely a Bang & Olufsen or Nakamichi, there will be no Shopper’s Stop, instead, you’ll see a Harrod’s or an Au Printemps.

When she inhales, she’ll take in the smell of some sophisticated perfume; a combination of the smell of leather and other expensive aromas.

A man, immaculately dressed in a black jacket and tie greets her with a plate full of some expensive canapés as she walks in, along with perhaps a glass of champagne.

The floor is covered with a soft, carpet into which her feet sink with delicious ease.

If all this happens your customer doesn’t need advertising to tell her that this is a luxury brand – her senses tell her that anyway. It’s the difference between seeing a man standing on a rooftop and shouting, “I’m funny! I’m funny!” and Groucho Marx saying, “Before I begin I should tell you I was born at a very young age.”

What’s even more interesting is that because all her senses have been telling her this, the young lady knows this mall is a luxury brand emotionally and viscerally – not just intellectually.

If the experience is appropriate and communicates your brand values, you’ll have a consumer who has the brand in her veins and her bones – not just in her mind – it’s a relationship that could approach the level of intimacy and depth of a religion.

And that is what a great service brand can do to a consumer – if it realizes that it cannot afford to remain at that level – it can (and must) become an experience brand.