Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Probably Deserved It

I saw a headline today where a 12-year-old boy was murdered by his 'friends' - knifed to death.

I read on, thinking, 'poor bastard.' Then in the second or third paragraph I read that young Abhishekh was the son of a auto rickshaw driver.

"Probably deserved it," was my first thought. I had assumed he was a bully and a toadie in imitation of his father.

Auto rickshaw drivers in Bangalore have such a bad reputation, that it extends to their children - at least in my mind. Isn't that unfortunate?

Then I saw another article about lawyers beating up two police officers - one of whom was female – then trying to strip the female officer. Pretty soon, lawyers will earn themselves the same reputation. When I hear the son of a lawyer has been killed, my first reaction will be, "Probably deserved it."

Is this really what the lawyers of Bangalore want? Because that's the way they're headed.

Monday, March 26, 2012

Bad Writing

Newspapers are full of horrendous writing. I'm amazed at how bad some of their grammar is - don't they have editors? Or are editors too lazy/incompetent/blind/ to see grammatical errors and correct them?


Two of my particular bugbears are the use of the word 'critical' and the constant use of 'braveheart' for hero.


 'Critical' has several meanings:
  1. inclined to find fault or to judge with severity, often too readily
  2. occupied with or skilled in criticism.
  3. involving skillful judgment as to truth, merit, etc.; judicial: acritical analysis.
  4. of or pertaining to critics or criticism: critical essays.
  5. providing textual variants, proposed emendations, etc.: a critical edition of Chaucer.
Nowhere is it mentioned that 'critical' can be substituted for critically ill, critically injured or in critical condition. 


It probably started when a person asked, "What is his condition, doctor?"


And the doctor answered, "Critical."


Then a friend or relative asked that person, "How is he?" 


The answer was, "Critical." 


So that now it's become a de facto replacement for critically ill. 


Whenever I hear somebody answer, 'critical,' I have to use supreme will power to put the brakes on my motormouth and suppress the horrid urge to ask, "Of what? The nurses? The doctors? The hospital?" 


Of course, I do realize that it's generally entirely the wrong time to correct somebody's English, so I hold my peace (Shakespeare!).


Now 'critical' is used entirely wrongly everywhere - even by people who are supposed to write good English.



Today's headline cries out, "Tibetan critical after setting self ablaze." 

This is profoundly nonsensical. The man was critical of the Chinese regime, so 'Critical Tibetan sets self ablaze' would have been correct - though perhaps not as informative. What would be correct is 'Tibetan critically ill after setting self ablaze." Somehow, we knock off the word 'condition' whenever we talk about critical.


As for braveheart - it's the name of a bad movie starring Mel Gibson in blue face paint, roaring obscenities in a Scottish accent. 


Braveheart! 


There's no such word. Why we Indians have adopted it as our very own is beyond me. Some moron/editor must have really, really, REALLY loved the movie and used the word, which was promptly latched on to by every other idiot (read journalist) out there. It has subsequently become common parlance.


I won't be surprised if the Indian Government starts awarding all its various medals to 'Bravehearts' instead of heroes. Sachin wins a Padmashree for being (hold your breath) a braveheart.


Utter balderdash!



Saturday, March 24, 2012

Traffic (Again)

The Deccan Herald had an article today about traffic accidents in Bangalore. They focused their attention (and blame) on youngsters who drive too fast. This was based on the fact that a young girl died recently on the NICE road because the young man who was at the wheel was going way too fast. There were also a bunch of quotes from interviews with young men who own powerful cars and love speeding.

I don't disagree with the article; speeding is a problem. But they're also being extremely unfair in their assessment in blaming only speeding.

I was recently on the NICE road myself and although I wasn't driving and we weren't speeding, I can tell you I felt the road is unsafe at any speed.

For one simple reason.

A lack of policing.

And policing matters. I remember while driving to Chennai, the instant we crossed the border into Tamilnadu, the trucks all moved over to the left – a simple result of better policing.

Anyway, back to the NICE road. Even doing less than 100 km/h on a good road, we had to weave between slow-moving traffic because large, heavy vehicles stick obdurately to the right hand (fast) lane as a corrupt Chief Minister sticks to his gaddi.

There is simply no moving them. While these trucking menaces are dawdling along at 60 km/h,  horning does as much good as a Lok Ayukta notice. 

When these truck-drivers are doing their Chief Ministerial act, the only option for a car is to go around them - from the left. The illegal side – which most of us don't even seem to know.

Which means that if the truck driver takes it into his thick head to move to the 'correct' lane, the car's driver will be minced meat.

There will be an accident.

And this is the problem not just with Bangalore, but India in general. Even Bombay – where the policing and lane discipline used to be so good – has lost the plot. On the sea-link, the other day, the same problem: slow moving traffic sitting in the fast lane and refusing to move.

Of course, that's not the only thing.

There's cellphone usage while driving, a complete lack of common sense, total ignorance of lane discipline, the idea that traffic lights are some sort of decorative feature invented by the traffic police for their own gratification and of course, the idea that letting somebody pass you or (heaven forbid!) letting somebody go at a cross-road, reduces the size of your penis (or possibly boobs in the case of women).

There is something seriously wrong with our national sense of what's wrong and what's right. You cannot jump up and down in support of Anna Hazare or claim to be anti-corruption, when your corruption is so obvious, high and wide public. I mean - you're on the roads pal. You're out there where everybody can see you breaking the rules. Everybody.

Our national, unabashed and completely blatant disregard for the law is not just symptomatic, it is endemic. It's rapidly becoming our national, distinguishing characteristic.

In fact, I believe there's no point in even talking about anti-corruption, until we route out the contradiction inherent in our own inability to control our baser instincts on the road.


Friday, March 23, 2012

Old Fashioned Music

I was watching X-Factor recently and I realized how totally out of date I am.

Boy!

Out of the four judges, I have never heard of Cee-Lo Green (what a name), Adam Levine, okay yes, I've heard of Maroon Five, Christina Aguilera yes I've heard of and don't like. 

The last guy, Blake Shelton I had also never heard of, but once I heard him on the show, I made an effort to get some of his stuff and found I like it - but then I like country and western music (which probably just evocatively demonstrates how old-fashioned I am).

So 50-50. Quite a bad score for somebody who claims to love music.

Anyway, I went to my iTunes collection and checked out my selection of favorite tunes. It has all the names that instantly say, "Old Man" in capital letters or maybe just "Daddy"?

Yup.

All the usual suspects: Bob Dylan (68 songs), The Beatles (28), Jethro Tull (9, but my favorites), The Rolling Stones (27), Foreigner (10, I know, more than Tull. I'm shameless), Steve Winwood (16, with and without Traffic), Creedence Clearwater Revival (12), Eric Clapton, Meatloaf, Curtis Mayfield, U2, Bob Marley, Neil Young, Bruce Springsteen, Dire Straits, Herman's Hermits, Uriah Heep . .

Some pop: Eurythmics, Paul Young, Isaac Hayes, Belinda Carlisle, Blondie (or are they classic rock?) 23 of U2's songs . . .

Of course, I also have Dolly Parton, Kenny Rogers, Charlie Rich, Glen Campbell, Johnny Cash, Cat Stevens, Al Stewart . . .

Some new stuff: Lady Antebellum, Plain White Tees and a few others.

Blues of course. Muddy Waters and the one of a kind, Van Morrison (33 of his songs - the second after Dylan).

In fact, on that collection, I have put together 712 songs - all of whose words I know. Not entirely in some cases, but enough to sing along.

All 60s, 70s and before that.

Very old-fashioned.

But what a memory boys and girls - like my dad told me some years ago, a mind like a frying pan - very wide and very shallow!

Thursday, March 22, 2012

Branding in the real estate space in India

“Real estate prices down 20%.” “Real estate players forced to release stockpiled property due to funds crunch.”

Headlines like these just about summarize the reason why real estate players need genuine branding and genuine brands – instead of advertising-based logos and promotional gimmickry.

The reality is that, up to now, most real estate players have been living in a cloud-cuckoo land of endless lines of buyers. They’ve been happily reaping the benefits of living in a seller’s market and ignored branding almost totally – replacing it with advertising.

Until a few months ago, all a promoter had to do is buy land, design a building, release an advertisement in the newspapers concerning an upcoming project and there would be takers. The next step would be to release yet another advertisement saying ‘project overbooked’, then go on to build the structure. And of course, rake in the moolah.

There was no thought behind the architect's design of the apartments or the building complex.

A mall would be built because it sounded like a good idea.

Who was going to stay in the apartment complex? Who was going to use the mall? The target audience was ill-defined or not defined at all.

As a result, it wasn’t clear whom you should target, it wasn’t clear where advertising should be placed and it wasn’t clear what kinds of shops would be in the mall.

With the near-collapse of the US economy – and therefore the world’s economy – this situation has changed. And real estate players must acknowledge the fact.

The selling of real estate must become more brand-oriented.

It’s as simple or as complicated as that.

Post Satyam, post the drop in real estate prices, post the tightening of funds, a real estate player can still command a premium and sell their property – if they are a brand.

And how can a real estate player build a brand?

In sum, real estate players – from large to small –  can make sure they can sell their product, even in the hardest of times. And it can happen in four seemingly simple steps:

1. They need to find out who their best customers are, why they buy real estate and what makes them tick. What this entails:

     a.    Research into consumer attitudes and acquiring an understanding of
            why people buy (the assumption is that it is a combination of an
            investment and a residence may be erroneous)

    b.    Examination of the company’s own strengths and weaknesses –
           there’s no point in building a residential complex if the
           company has no skill or interest in maintaining it

    c.    Examination of the area surrounding a property – what would fit in
           there? More apartments, offices or should you try to build an
           entertainment center?

    d.    Examination of the environment as a whole – if the economy is in a
           slump there is surely little point in building a high-end residential
           complex – probably a middle-income construction would make
           more sense

2. Put together a way to talk to them in a language they understand with a promise they’ll buy. What this means:

    a.   The development of a communication plan that is geared towards
          a particular target audience making them promises they’ll buy

3. Communicate that promise to them through brand activation and communication

    a.    Should there be advertising or will direct marketing do the trick?
           Should you try events, road shows and the like, do you think an
          unusual promotional offer could make a difference?

4. Measure how the branding strategy is working

    a.     Finally, there is no point in having a brand unless goods are sold.
           So a real estate company must have some way of tracking how
           their branding efforts are working

The first step is to understand that a brand in the real estate area is a lot more than just the name. (Although it’s interesting to see how real estate barons are undoing what our politicians did and giving their projects names like Dorchester, Windsor, Piccadilly and so on.)

Defining the target audience will begin with why they buy. Is it an investment? Is it to stay in? To work in? Why?

That knowledge will lead to calculated decisions as to which facilities are important to which target audience and which are not. Is a swimming pool really necessary in a city like Bangalore where the water is arctic most of the year? Does the complex need wireless connectivity? How much parking will it need for guests and visitors?

Do people like openness? Or do they want more light? Do they like small windows or big ones?

Currently all this is left to the architect’s whims and fancies.

I was at a meeting recently where the architect was waxing eloquent about how his building was going to ‘promote communal living’ by making the common areas more inviting. He felt that people wanted to go back to the ‘old times’ when neighbors were all your friends.

I asked him whether he had bothered to check whether consumers actually wanted ‘communal living’ or a return to the ‘old times’. In my experience most young people want to move out of the ghettos of religion and caste where their parents stayed.

The answer was no, but he felt that this was a good idea.

Whoops. Maybe, maybe not – I don’t know; and I wouldn’t venture an opinion until I’ve checked it with a large enough sample of consumers.

And that’s the point – nobody in the real estate industry has really spoken to consumers. And it’s definitely time they did.

Once they have, they’ll know whether consumers actually want a flat in a complex built to ‘imitate the waterways of Venice’. Or if they would they simply see it as a breeding ground for mosquitoes.

Once they’ve done their research, they will come to conclusions which will undoubtedly influence the design of the buildings they construct.

This is important because a real estate brand is not merely a function of advertising and communication – it’s also a function of the buildings that come up.

So if your buildings have to reflect your brand, it is essential that you understand what kind of brand and product consumers will buy in bad times.

In recessionary times, to sell apartments like potatoes and onions is to ask for trouble.

The next step in brand activation must take into account the fact that there is more to be done than just the basics.

It is no longer enough to be good and well-priced – every product needs the ‘wow’ factor. And since it is really no longer possible to wow people with your product you have to wow people with your service.

Apollo Hospitals has been wondering why, since all patients rate them as the best in clinical care and as the go-to place in an emergency, patients still rate them needing improvement. The answer can be summed up in one word.

Service.

And that’s the reality of every product in every product category – brand activation must include improvement of service standards.

Where do consumers go to book an apartment? Who takes them across to see the model flat? How will they be transported there? Can they trust the company to deliver on time, with all the amenities promised?

It’s all going to be very important. In today’s climate, the brand’s behavior is going to sell real estate – not mere availability.

Finally, the real estate giants need to find out how consumers view their brands on an ongoing basis. If they’re seen as rapacious, greedy companies set up to make a few people rich they’re bound to find the going tough in hard times. On the other hand, if they’re seen as friendly people who actually bring people affordable and desirable dwelling places, they’ll find the going easier.

And that’s what a brand does – make people your friends. And that’s why branding in the real estate area is so necessary – especially in times where money, trust and the desire to spend are in short supply.

The final and obvious question is the most fundamental – how much will all this cost?

The extent and depth of what you can do will obviously depend on the funds you have available – the larger the number of projects, the larger the cost. However, if a brand can become the second-ranked national player without using mass media of any kind for over three years, it should be possible to build a real estate brand economically and efficiently.

Taking a look at the kind and amount of branding undertaken by real estate players it should be possible to save a minimum of 25% merely by improving the quality of advertising: sharpening its focus, sharpening its audience and addressing it and finally, by reducing spends on mass media and redeploying these funds into below-the-line publicity measures including PR and events.

In sum, branding in the real estate sector is most definitely not a luxury in this climate – it is a necessity. At the same time, it need not be an expensive necessity – there are ways of creating a robust brand without spending irrational sums of money.

Wednesday, March 21, 2012

Management Schools and Their Branding

Just read SatheeshKrishnamurthy at Marketing Maayaajaalam. He was ranting about why most management schools don't bother with branding.


Relevant in some ways - particularly how he talks about it.


But, the reality is that most management schools really don't need to do any branding whatsoever.


Branding is a way to increase sales. A way to increase awareness. A way to contact your target audience.


Do any management schools need to do any of those things?


I was doing some work with Symbiosis and I found some amazing statistics. One that stayed in my head is that they got over 7,00,000 applications that year and they charged Rs.200 per application form. That's over Rs.14crore on just applications. 


Can you imagine how much they make on fees and all the other stuff they do? 


They make it coming and going.


And Symbiosis is in the top ten but not on the level reserved for IIM A, B and C. Despite that, they don't have to or need to do any branding - whether it comes to the inside the institutions, in terms of signage, colors or decor. Or outside, with things like brochures, cards, logos and so on. 


I suppose branding might (I emphasize 'might') be valuable for the level two and three institutions, but how are they ever going to position themselves to match the IIMs? Not possible, I should think. 


Unless, like ISB, they do things entirely differently and get right up into that top rung - not through branding, but through their actions.


My view is the only branding that management schools need is internal and function-related. If they want to stand out they have to stand out with course, faculty and methodology.


Which, if you come to think of it, is also branding. 


Just not communication.

Analysis Without Paralysis

In advertising we used to talk a lot about 'paralysis by analysis', but actually, if you're smart about it, analysis leads to action.

However, we need to use practical, simple means of analysis.

As I recall, the normal means of analyzing a situation was to put all the figures up on a board and sit around in a large team and frown at them.

Yet analysis is merely putting a structure on thinking to make interpretation of an issue easier.

In point of fact, there are techniques for analysis. Simple, easy-to-use techniques that are equally easy to learn.

For example, one of the techniques I found particularly useful was the idea of a Matrix, which is nothing more than a grid with as many cells as are needed to clarify a problem.

The Hercule Poirot Plan
For example, suppose a suspect in a crime is answering a detective's questions. The detective wonders whether he is being truthful or not. Which means he sees only two scenarios: guilty or not guilty.

But actually there are four essential scenarios. But you can only see it if you look at it as a matrix.



Subject is telling the truth
Subject is lying
Subject guilty
Subject not guilty


That gives you four possible scenarios:

1. The subject is telling the truth and he is guilty
2. The subject is telling the truth and he is not guilty
3. The subject is lying and he is guilty
4. The subject is lying and he is not guilty

It all adds up to a situation where by using a technique as simple as a matrix, you see possibilities you would never have seen earlier.

As I said in an earlier blog, both analysis and creativity are basically techniques and can be learned. It's not something that's dominated by the wonderful minds that come out of IIM and IIT (I'm not being sarcastic - I've worked with some of these guys and they're superb). In fact, I've taught a bunch of advertising and communication students these techniques - and they loved it.

The reality is you can learn them too. No matter who you are.

If you want to, of course.


Monday, March 19, 2012

Traffic And The New Rules

There was an article in the Deccan Herald today about our wonderful fellow Bangaloreans feel about the new and much higher fines that are going to be levied for traffic violations.

There were some supporters of course. (Three cheers to them).

However, undoubtedly expressing the majority opinion, one young lady opined, "It will be a burden on the common man."

Well, maybe, dear lady, the common man should stop breaking the law?

There is a whacking great road divider on Assaye Road, especially where it joins Wheeler Road in Bangalore.

The idea is that you should stay on the left of the divider.

Sounds A for apple?

Not for our Bangalore boys and girls. They don't know this. They think a road divider is a decorative element put there for some strange and nefarious purpose by the authorities. It is a mere obstruction up with which they will not put.

So they blissfully ignore it.

As a result, when you're turning right, you have these heroes in their cars and two-wheelers speeding towards to you from the right - when you're least expecting it. The chances of an accident at this point go up 100%. Not to mention the wear and tear on your nerves.

Of course, the Karnataka Cowboys are doing nothing about this.

 In fact, the other day, I saw one of them trying to catch one of these law-breakers. He did, successfully.

Then, like the fish on the Cauvery, he threw the pond scum back into the whirling waters of Bangalore traffic.

Turns out the law-breaker was a fellow police officer.

I assume the Cowboys don't bother because if these geniuses of driving, these Schumacher wannabes are caught, they can always scream, "Burden on the common man!" Or whine, "Human rights violation!" and call for help from those great upholders of the law and human rights in Karnataka.

I'm talking about our worthy hooligans in black. Our lawyers, whose only view of the law of the land seems to be to find innovative and mostly violent ways break the law of the land.

And we want to be a civilized nation. When we can't even obey our own laws, which, unfortunately, are created for our own safety.

Not for our convenience.

As you may have deduced, I am in favor of these increased fines. I just hope they'll be properly implemented as a deterrent, not used as a means to blackmail motorists into giving our policemen more bribes.

Well, I can always live in hope, can't I?

Diabetes and Life

I've been working out. Maintain my diet. I keep my weight under control. I have only a slight paunch - no real middle-aged spread.

And my sugars are still out of control.

That I guess is life. A place and time where thousands of people can drink themselves silly, eat like the proverbial pig and still keep their sugars under control.

Whereas I live a disciplined life and bingo.

Sugar, sugar, anything's my candy.

Now I may have to wear an insulin pump. The idea itself is repugnant.

It will mean I have to stop doing all kinds of things. It will affect my golf, my exercise routine, my life.

It's an utter and complete pain in the ass.


Sunday, March 18, 2012

Creativity and Intelligence

Think of a pink elephant in a bathtub.

Think of your worst enemy.

Think of your mother.

What just happened?

Did you dream up a pink elephant in a bathtub? Did you imagine what it would look like? Whether the bathtub would crack? What would happen to the taps?


Did you think of your worst enemy? His bad breath? His habit of screaming at people? Or his venomous ways? 

What about your mother? Did  you think of her cooking? Her warmth? Her embrace? Her black hair streaked with grey?

If you're smart enough to read this blog, I can tell you one thing.

You did. 

Because, basically, you used your imagination. 

Anybody who has intelligence and ambition has an imagination.

Even if it's just the ability to see yourself sitting on a motorcycle, or behind the wheel of your favorite car.

That's because creativity and intelligence are just two sides of a coin. If you are creative you will be intelligent. And if you're intelligent you are creative.

My definition of creative, therefore; it is harnessed imagination.

All it takes is training and a particularly focused method of thinking to be creative - and it can be learnt.

That's not to say it is easy. 

But then neither is logical, analytical thinking. And that doesn't come easy either - even to the most intelligent people in the world.

Yet, both can be learnt. There's nothing sacred about creativity or analysis.

Nothing.


Saturday, March 17, 2012

Why Advertising Is Old-Fashioned

I've been told that advertising has changed in the past six years. That I'm an old fuddy-duddy.

Completely out of it.

Outdated.

Irrelevant.

I'm sorry. They're completely and irredeemably wrong. Advertising today is facing an existential crisis. And it still refuses to give up its old paradigm.

So what is the old paradigm?

Simply that there are three categories of people in an advertising agency:

  1. 1. The flippant, superficial (but important) arty-farty creative guys
  2. 2. The serious, committed business servicing chaps
  3. 3. And the analytical planners who really understand the clients’ business

What this means is that people have labels and certain freedoms - I translate that as a lack of responsibility.


Take the Oh-So-Very-Creative Guys

In this paradigm, these ladies and gentlemen are allowed to be temperamental. They're given permission to throw tantrums. They can be divas and prima donnas. They can ignore mundane realities like business results, profitability and results. All they need to think about is winning awards on occasion. And meeting deadlines regularly.

Oh yes, that big fat word awards.

The latest story is that foreign investors are willing to pay more for shares in an award-winning company than a money-making advertising agency.

So the effort is to win more awards.

Which means fake advertising, for fake clients or for a kindly sucker who is willing to let the 'award-winning' work run in some inconsequential publication or channel.

That is, of course, until the same creative person founds his own advertising agency. Or is promoted to run one.

Then, suddenly, he or she learns all about business.

He or she is also taught very young that the other two functions are to be considered the ENEMY.


Now What About The Hard-Heads

The servicing guys are supposed to be the hard-headed 'business' types. They look at the money, they look at the bottom-line, they also decide if a piece of (not award-wining) advertising will 'work' or not. They decide, in their pragmatic fashion, if the typography works, if the layout is alright, if the script makes sense.

Then they take it to the client.

Who promptly changes everything, sending the servicing boy back to the agency to force those art-farty creative types to make the changes.

It's irrelevant that most servicing lads and laddettes have not been trained to understand the difference between good and bad typography or layout.

And even more irrelevant that 90% of servicing lads and laddettes can't read a balance sheet or a profit and loss statement or even understand the importance of cash-flow.

But they do understand how to get out 'good' creative. But never great creative.

And since great creative is the target of any creative director, to servicing guys and gals, they are the ENEMY.


Strategy and Planning

The unfortunate reality is that planners are probably the most highly qualified people in an agency. They're all MBAs and are generally smarter and more well-read than their servicing counterparts. Unfortunately, for the most part, they don't know how far they should take what they do.

They're supposed to be the consumer's voice in the agency.

What does that voice say?

Generally, "I don't understand this."

Which is a death knell for great advertising. And completely and utterly wrong.

Because it's the planner's logical mind speaking - not his heart. And consumers respond from the heart.

Which is what makes her (oddly planners are generally female) the ENEMY to creative people. Whereas she should be your most treasured ally.


What Does This Mean?

The net result is everything is seen from this perspective.

I was in a meeting where an agency chief told me he didn't think what was the case five years ago, applied today. The concept was 'old-fashioned' in his words.

He is seriously deluded. Basic concepts will never change. For example, in typography, ideas like the right choice of typeface, kerning and alignment will need the same basics from now until the time when we all stop reading.

Briefing will always and forever involve a target audience description, a unique selling proposition and a tone of voice. Without that no advertisements will ever be created.

Nothing has changed. Nothing will change.

What has changed is what is now demanded from every service industry. What is the expectation from every service industry. Which can be summed up in one word.

More.

Advertising people need to be more knowledgeable, quicker on the uptake, faster to help, faster to react and way, way smarter. They need to not only know more about their clients' business, they need to know more about other business areas, so that they can bring to bear new perspectives. The old 'get the ad approved and then run after artworks' style of functioning is no longer going to be enough.

Forget servicing people, creative people are going to have to understand business and prove that they understand business on a regular basis.

And the divide and rule policy that governs most agencies needs to be thrown out of the window. Creative, servicing and planning need to work together - with a clear understanding of each others' roles and responsibilities.

Sounds simple. And most agencies will tell you they've done that.

I'm not in an agency, so I can't tell you whether that is the truth or not. All I can say is based on what I see on TV and in the press.

And I can say one thing: if they have, it doesn't show.

Friday, March 16, 2012

Some questions to advertising people and advertisers

When you're promoting a modern concept like posting a film on youtube through your smart 'phone, why would you use such obvious and predictable clichés? I mean that villain looks like something out of an old-fashioned dacoit movie starring Sunil Dutt.

When you're talking high-tech and futuristic, why would the Toshiba commercial be so old-fashioned? "Technology that defines HD' and the line is 'leading innovation'. So why aren't the ads innovative? Haven't they heard the story of th can who stood on top of a building shouting, "I'm funny! I'm funny!"? (He isn't).

Why does every hair dye ad look the same as the next?

Why does every Garnier ad star a bimbo who glowers at the camera and snarls, 'take care.' like he (or she) is coming to getchya?

Skincare creams seem to end-to-end demos. I understand demos and the need for them - I worked on P&G after all - but isn't this taking things too far?

I have been watching a program - okay, an English program - and the ads were:

1. Dexter - okay pass
2/ Garnier Men Powerlight - John Abraham as the bimbo
3. Sunsilk Keratinology - a bimbo as a bimbo
4. Frooti - a 'slice of life' commercial that is a slice of nobody's life
5. Ambipure - how gross can you get?
6. Nestlé Cappucino Eclairs - bad Italian joke
7. Toshiba Power TV - - already discussed
8. Appyfizz - some really shitty jokes
9. Ponds Age Miracle - man, how incredibly boring, but a HUGE promise. I'm sure it 'works'
10. Touch - ad for a new serial - okay forget it.

When you think that the choice of the best of the lot is between Frooti and Appyfizz you realize that Sturgeon's Law still applies. 90% of everything is shit.

It was true in 2001 and it's true in 2011.

So, one last question.

Why are so many copywriters, art directors and account executives satisfied with producing shit?

Wednesday, March 14, 2012

In Search of Greatness

When you read about Steve Jobs, Picasso, Hemingway, Feynman, Oppenheimer and a bunch of other acknowledged high IQ characters who changed their worlds, you get to wondering something.

Do you have to be obnoxious to be great?

But when I read the biographies again carefully, I realized something - that 'obnoxious' quality is a just another word for an adamant refusal to compromise. And people in authority hate men and women who refuse to compromise.

But, the ability to compromise is, simply put, the first step on the short step taking you down from 'great' to 'good.' And although there is a fair amount of 'good' in the world - there is not nearly enough 'great'.

That's why, when I read Steve Jobs' biography, he reminded me so much of Mohammed Khan. From his finickiness and total integrity when it came to the work to his insistence that every single detail be 'right' - including the way the paintings were put up in his home or at office.

It was that integrity that prevented those of us who worked at Enterprise from falling into a trap that so many agencies have succumbed to in the recent past.

They've been entrapped by some very succulent bait.

And the 'bait', when it comes to advertising, are certain phrases that are pure, unadulterated cyanide to the search for greatness. Take a few examples of those very frequently heard poison pills: 'Just this once forget standards', 'this client doesn't deserve quality' 'this one isn't for the awards'. And as a corollary, probably the worst phrase of all; 'let's do some award-winning stuff'.

Translate these phrases and you understand how they are the Nathuram Godse of ideas.

Take them one by one.

Poison pill 1: 'Just this once forget standards'
This would have meant that an iPod may have been launched 6 months earlier - but it probably woudnt have been half as successful. The software would have been 'buggy' the hardware imperfect even the finish raw.

Similarly, if you decide to go slow on typography, what right do you have to maintain high standards on photography? If you can muck around with copy, why should you be fussed about headlines? If you don't care about video versus film, why should you care about your script?

The reality is that once you start ignoring one standard, what excuse do you have for harping madly on another equally subjective standard? One excuse, just one, starts you on a slippery slope to damnation.

Poison pill 2: 'this client doesn't deserve quality'
If any client - I repeat any client - big, small, medium doesn't deserve quality who does? If a client refuses to accept outstanding work, it's not because of his or her lack of taste, aesthetic sense or appreciation of my amazing talent. It's because I haven't been able to convince him to take his medicine.

And ideas are medicine. Bitter medicine. And like children, clients need to be persuaded to eat it.

Poison pill 3: 'this one isn't for the awards'
You speaketh sooth mate. No work is for awards. Or at least no work should be for awards. Ever.

Advertising is paid communication for commercial purposes. It has a job to do. It must sell - maybe not a product, but an idea, an image or a brand.

It's not meant to sell itself.

But the gap between commercial art and fine art is specious, in any case. All art is about selling. Every artist aspires to sell his art - to make a living. Rest assured, no artist wants to end up like Van Gogh - selling for millions while he's mouldering in a pauper's grave.

Advertising just has to sell the subject of its art. That's the only real difference.

Poison pill 4: 'let's do some award-winning stuff'
The assumption behind that is that the regular stuff need not be any good. But to win awards we have to do freaky, weird, never-seen-before work that has absolutely no chance of working in the marketplace. This is advertising 'art'. In reality, advertising that doesn't 'work' isn't advertising. God knows what it is, but it's not advertising.

The only-for-awards work is deeply dishonest, venal and unethical. And it seems to be done all the time.

Weirdly, shareholders and clients seem to buy into that venality. Share prices rise with every award you win. The more awards you win, the more clients call you to pitch.

It's idiotic.

At Enterprise and Trikaya, the understanding was that we would only do great work.

All the time.

Every single time.

For every client.

We would look at every detail, we would work the typography, we would slog for better photography - even in dealer ads or 50cc nothing ads.

And we would win awards for them.

It's time to get back to the hunt for great. It's time to get back to doing great stuff for every client every time.

They deserve it. But more important, we deserve it.

Thursday, March 08, 2012

On Being A Teacher

I met a bunch of my ex-colleagues from HTA for dinner today. I quit way back in 2001. It was astounding to me how many of the erstwhile members of my team told me how much they appreciated all that I had done for them.

"Ill never forget all that you taught me."

"I still use the things you had taught me till today."

"You were such a good person to work with."

And best of all, from a servicing guy, "You had the bad luck to be in the wrong place at the wrong time."

Ah hell. It's always better to look forward than to look back.

Right now, I sincerely believe that I can use my experience in advertising, teaching and branding to add huge value to advertising agencies.

I believe that they could use my knowledge to improve the skills of their people.

Finally, I sincerely believe that I am a great teacher. Possibly as good a teacher as I was a creative director.

Even if they don't want me to join them, I know agencies could use me effectively.

It's not just about loving advertising.

I do.

It's about loving teaching as well. And having knowledge that very people in advertising have.

And being willing to share it.

I always have. And always will.

Indan Advertising Typography Sucks

When I was at Enterprise, there was a time when both Trikaya and we were doing the most amazing work. Work that's still pathbreaking.

We won.

Award after award. Client after client.

The standards of typography and design we had back then were up there with the best in the world. We could see it. We knew we could have beaten the best. And when Chris, Jackie, Stewart and a bunch of others went abroad that's most assuredly what they did.

Those were the standards of typography design that I tried to import into O&M, when I worked there. Followed by Sista Saatchi & Saatchi and finally, HTA-Bangalore (I couldn't color an entire ocean differently). For a while, when I moved to McCann, I thought the habit of great typography and design had actually taken.

I thought we'd won.

But (yeah, there's always a 'but') in the recent past, I've been reconstructing my Atticus Merit Award winning presentation on typography with some real-life examples and have been trying to find some 'real' examples of great Indian typography and design - by 'real' I mean stuff that hasn't been created for Cannes.

Let me tell you, gentle reader, it's been a Herculean task.

I've been going through the newspapers, DNA and the Deccan Herald and magazines like, India Today, Outlook, Man, GQ, The Week and Open. Finding an ad that sings to you the way Trikaya's or Enterprise's advertisements used to sing to us sitting in OBM (the earlier avatar which Piyush, Ramesh and I joined).

And what did I find?

Nada, nothing, zero, zilch, squat, zero, zot.

Finding a good advertisement in an everyday publication is as difficult as finding an Indian advertising guy who doesn't want to go to Cannes.

Anyway, to go all old fart on you, I remember, when I was in O&M Madras, Ramesh had cut out a bunch of Enterprise's ads and put them up on our soft board with the headline: 'Are they outDOing us?' Well it was OBM and we still did think puns were great . . .

I still remember one of Rajan Nair's lines, "Australia? You want me to travel 1000 miles to see a bunch of kangaroos?" from Enterprise. Who can forget Trikaya's 'Nude Models Wanted'? Or the amazing Mauritius ads. Or all those wonderful ads - which included great lines - for Vadilal.

An aside. Everybody else in advertising thought that what made Vadilal great were the photographs - but when Ogilvy tried to duplicate the photography (with the same photographer) they only successfully showed off their ineptitude, both advertising-wise and sales-wise.

To make a real Vadilal advertisement, Mohammed insisted that the headlines and the design were equally important - that they all worked together. Let me tell you, from personal experience, that writing a Vadilal headline was no easy ask. Neither was coming up with a Vadilal visual to be photographed.

Above all, the work was inspiring. What it did do was inspire us to do more work like that.

Which leads me to the next, important point. Only work which is great and out there in the open in the newspapers and on television can do that.

Unfortunately, the great work that's out there today seems to be limited to the months before the Cannes and One Show Entries need to be done. They're released in inconsequential publications and finally, they don't matter.

Yet, the greatest, the best advertising is the stuff that's out there. The stuff that generates sales, excites eyeballs, gets spoken about, written about and made bigger than it actually is.

Ogilvy is still doing some stuff like that - but only on television. Their press has devolved to what it was in the dark days before Mac, Sonal and gang took it ahead.

And the typography. It's almost retarded.

Forget about concepts like kerning, or alignment, even the basic idea that you shouldn't use more than two typefaces in an advertisement is ignored.

So many advertisements today are an abomination.

I remember, when I joined O&M, one of the first arguments I had with Titan was that consumers don't see what typeface you use, they read the words, depending on whether the advertisement looks good or not. I had a fierce fight to change the typeface of the baseline to match the rest of the advertisement. The same argument Chris D'Rozario had with Dunlop.

We won.

Today, I saw an ad for Chevrolet which was utterly, completely gruesome. It made Frankenstein's monster look positively ravishing. Something like 8 different typefaces, different sizes, different colors, God knows how many logos. As David Ogilvy once said about an ad created within O&M New York, "This looks like an advertisement created by somebody who's heard of advertising and has been told about advertising, but has never seen an advertisement in his life."

They lost.

Indian advertising lost.

And every Indian lost one small battle to bad taste and mediocrity.

In the 80s and early 90s I seriously thought we were changing the future of advertising. That we would be doing typography and art and things that were up there with the best - but on a regular basis. Every single day. For every client.

We lost.

Tuesday, March 06, 2012

Ugly

Have you seen the new Cadbury's Silk commercials? What incredibly ugly people and the incredible ugliness of chocolate all over their faces. That smarmy-looking woman in the middle, in the movie theatre commercial; that nitwitted teenager in the stairs commercial (I've literally never seen an uglier person). People never look uglier than when they're eating and here's an object lesson in how to make eating look even uglier.

Hideous.

Being a Creative Director

I've been watching a lot of TV lately in this period of no-job and no-work.

A few conclusions:

Firstly, Indian serials are insanely bad.
I mean they truly plumb depths of awfulness that have to be seen to be believed. The acting is grotesque, reminiscent of the 60s style of movie acting. Some of the actresses are reasonably attractive, but, for the most part - especially the older women - are just plain gruesome. As for the men, a bigger collection of cardboard cut-outs would be difficult to find.

Secondly, television news in English has completely lost the plot
For the last three days, all they've been covering is projections of what the polls will deliver. They then debate what will happen if the polls are accurate (a big, fat 'if'). In the process, they are not only manufacturing news, they are ignoring the real happening news. For example, it doesn't seem to matter enough to Arnab Goswami to focus his histrionic mock outrage on what is happening with the lawyers in Bangalore. How utterly corrupt they are and how they are flouting the law at every turn. What matters more is an opinion poll that cannot accurately predict what will happen two days hence.

Today, when the results have been announced, they conduct the same interviews with the same set of nitwits posing the same dim questions.

The only difference is that they now have the real numbers to talk about. And even that seems iffy, because NDTV, TimesNow, HeadlinesToday and CNN-IBN are all reporting different figures.

Thirdly, Indian advertising still follows Sturgeon's Law
I learnt this from Harlan Ellison's 'The Glass Teat" which profoundly changed my life. Sturgeon's Law states that 90% of everything is crap. There is only 10% of anything that is good, worthwhile and true in the world. My belief (and Harlan's) is that you should strive to produce stuff that is part of the 10%. But that's an aside.

Sturgeon's Law had two corollaries and they apply to advertising as well (I'm paraphrasing here);

1. The existence of immense quantities of trash in Indian advertising is admitted and it is regrettable; but it is no more unnatural than the existence of trash anywhere.

2. The best Indian advertising is as good as the best advertising in any country.

However, I still believe some of the Vintellicepts I did at Vertebrand was as good as the 10% in current India advertising. I mean the stuff that isn't utter crap.

So do I think I could still crack a creative director's job. Yes, my liege. I could probably apply good boot to the gluteus maximus of most the current run of creative directors.

Of course, this is theorizing; nobody's going to offer me a job now (too old).

Monday, March 05, 2012

Are Lawyers Victims of Bad Branding

The lawyers in Bangalore seem to be the most lawless coots on God's earth.

If journalists are to be believed.

On the other hand, since the lawyers tried to attack the journalists, can they be believed?

Ummm question mark.

Of course, the unfortunate fact that the lawyers went on a rampage not a month ago has nothing to do with anything.


Their unfortunate act of bringing the whole city of Bangalore to a grinding halt is irrelevant.

That this was because one of them was stopped by a policeman for carrying three lawyers on a motorcycle, none of them wearing helmets, is also quite inconsequential.

What really bothered these hooligans in lawyer's gowns is the idea that somebody - anybody - should dare to assume that the law actually applies to lawyers! How utterly ridiculous.

What a fallacious assumption.

On the other hand, consider the world they live in. Where a perfectly honest man can lose his entire life's savings because a judge has been bribed. Where a defendant can on stand in court and perjure herself - and when her lawyer is asked why she is allowed to lie, the female lawyers has the temerity to answer, "That's all we do in court, isn't it? Lie?"

In that sort of a world, how can we expect lawyers to believe that laws actually apply to them as well. They see their ability to browbeat a policeman on the stand as a license to browbeat the man on the roads as well.

Who's to blame them?

We just must feel sorry for the poor men and women. I mean imagine living in a world where the last great and reasonably credible pillar of Indian society is crumbling around you. And you're one of those making it crumble.

Wouldn't that be a kicker?

The sort of thing that allows you to believe that as a lawyer, you are indeed above the law. Because the law is scum.

So, in sum, is it because they went on a rampage a month ago that the men in black are getting a bad rap? In short, even though they're completely innocent this time around, they're being forced to carry the journalists' can because of what they did a month ago? Bad branding in short?

Or is it because, if truth in advertising has any value, they rioted for a ludicrous reason the last time, it is not unnatural that everybody would believe they're still the same set of goons?

A question to consider.