We won.
Award after award. Client after client.
The standards of typography and design we had back then were up there with the best in the world. We could see it. We knew we could have beaten the best. And when Chris, Jackie, Stewart and a bunch of others went abroad that's most assuredly what they did.
Those were the standards of typography design that I tried to import into O&M, when I worked there. Followed by Sista Saatchi & Saatchi and finally, HTA-Bangalore (I couldn't color an entire ocean differently). For a while, when I moved to McCann, I thought the habit of great typography and design had actually taken.
I thought we'd won.
But (yeah, there's always a 'but') in the recent past, I've been reconstructing my Atticus Merit Award winning presentation on typography with some real-life examples and have been trying to find some 'real' examples of great Indian typography and design - by 'real' I mean stuff that hasn't been created for Cannes.
Let me tell you, gentle reader, it's been a Herculean task.
I've been going through the newspapers, DNA and the Deccan Herald and magazines like, India Today, Outlook, Man, GQ, The Week and Open. Finding an ad that sings to you the way Trikaya's or Enterprise's advertisements used to sing to us sitting in OBM (the earlier avatar which Piyush, Ramesh and I joined).
And what did I find?
Nada, nothing, zero, zilch, squat, zero, zot.
Finding a good advertisement in an everyday publication is as difficult as finding an Indian advertising guy who doesn't want to go to Cannes.
Anyway, to go all old fart on you, I remember, when I was in O&M Madras, Ramesh had cut out a bunch of Enterprise's ads and put them up on our soft board with the headline: 'Are they outDOing us?' Well it was OBM and we still did think puns were great . . .
I still remember one of Rajan Nair's lines, "Australia? You want me to travel 1000 miles to see a bunch of kangaroos?" from Enterprise. Who can forget Trikaya's 'Nude Models Wanted'? Or the amazing Mauritius ads. Or all those wonderful ads - which included great lines - for Vadilal.
An aside. Everybody else in advertising thought that what made Vadilal great were the photographs - but when Ogilvy tried to duplicate the photography (with the same photographer) they only successfully showed off their ineptitude, both advertising-wise and sales-wise.
To make a real Vadilal advertisement, Mohammed insisted that the headlines and the design were equally important - that they all worked together. Let me tell you, from personal experience, that writing a Vadilal headline was no easy ask. Neither was coming up with a Vadilal visual to be photographed.
Above all, the work was inspiring. What it did do was inspire us to do more work like that.
Which leads me to the next, important point. Only work which is great and out there in the open in the newspapers and on television can do that.
Unfortunately, the great work that's out there today seems to be limited to the months before the Cannes and One Show Entries need to be done. They're released in inconsequential publications and finally, they don't matter.
Yet, the greatest, the best advertising is the stuff that's out there. The stuff that generates sales, excites eyeballs, gets spoken about, written about and made bigger than it actually is.
Ogilvy is still doing some stuff like that - but only on television. Their press has devolved to what it was in the dark days before Mac, Sonal and gang took it ahead.
And the typography. It's almost retarded.
Forget about concepts like kerning, or alignment, even the basic idea that you shouldn't use more than two typefaces in an advertisement is ignored.
So many advertisements today are an abomination.
I remember, when I joined O&M, one of the first arguments I had with Titan was that consumers don't see what typeface you use, they read the words, depending on whether the advertisement looks good or not. I had a fierce fight to change the typeface of the baseline to match the rest of the advertisement. The same argument Chris D'Rozario had with Dunlop.
We won.
Today, I saw an ad for Chevrolet which was utterly, completely gruesome. It made Frankenstein's monster look positively ravishing. Something like 8 different typefaces, different sizes, different colors, God knows how many logos. As David Ogilvy once said about an ad created within O&M New York, "This looks like an advertisement created by somebody who's heard of advertising and has been told about advertising, but has never seen an advertisement in his life."
They lost.
Indian advertising lost.
And every Indian lost one small battle to bad taste and mediocrity.
In the 80s and early 90s I seriously thought we were changing the future of advertising. That we would be doing typography and art and things that were up there with the best - but on a regular basis. Every single day. For every client.
We lost.
No comments:
Post a Comment