Saturday, March 17, 2012

Why Advertising Is Old-Fashioned

I've been told that advertising has changed in the past six years. That I'm an old fuddy-duddy.

Completely out of it.

Outdated.

Irrelevant.

I'm sorry. They're completely and irredeemably wrong. Advertising today is facing an existential crisis. And it still refuses to give up its old paradigm.

So what is the old paradigm?

Simply that there are three categories of people in an advertising agency:

  1. 1. The flippant, superficial (but important) arty-farty creative guys
  2. 2. The serious, committed business servicing chaps
  3. 3. And the analytical planners who really understand the clients’ business

What this means is that people have labels and certain freedoms - I translate that as a lack of responsibility.


Take the Oh-So-Very-Creative Guys

In this paradigm, these ladies and gentlemen are allowed to be temperamental. They're given permission to throw tantrums. They can be divas and prima donnas. They can ignore mundane realities like business results, profitability and results. All they need to think about is winning awards on occasion. And meeting deadlines regularly.

Oh yes, that big fat word awards.

The latest story is that foreign investors are willing to pay more for shares in an award-winning company than a money-making advertising agency.

So the effort is to win more awards.

Which means fake advertising, for fake clients or for a kindly sucker who is willing to let the 'award-winning' work run in some inconsequential publication or channel.

That is, of course, until the same creative person founds his own advertising agency. Or is promoted to run one.

Then, suddenly, he or she learns all about business.

He or she is also taught very young that the other two functions are to be considered the ENEMY.


Now What About The Hard-Heads

The servicing guys are supposed to be the hard-headed 'business' types. They look at the money, they look at the bottom-line, they also decide if a piece of (not award-wining) advertising will 'work' or not. They decide, in their pragmatic fashion, if the typography works, if the layout is alright, if the script makes sense.

Then they take it to the client.

Who promptly changes everything, sending the servicing boy back to the agency to force those art-farty creative types to make the changes.

It's irrelevant that most servicing lads and laddettes have not been trained to understand the difference between good and bad typography or layout.

And even more irrelevant that 90% of servicing lads and laddettes can't read a balance sheet or a profit and loss statement or even understand the importance of cash-flow.

But they do understand how to get out 'good' creative. But never great creative.

And since great creative is the target of any creative director, to servicing guys and gals, they are the ENEMY.


Strategy and Planning

The unfortunate reality is that planners are probably the most highly qualified people in an agency. They're all MBAs and are generally smarter and more well-read than their servicing counterparts. Unfortunately, for the most part, they don't know how far they should take what they do.

They're supposed to be the consumer's voice in the agency.

What does that voice say?

Generally, "I don't understand this."

Which is a death knell for great advertising. And completely and utterly wrong.

Because it's the planner's logical mind speaking - not his heart. And consumers respond from the heart.

Which is what makes her (oddly planners are generally female) the ENEMY to creative people. Whereas she should be your most treasured ally.


What Does This Mean?

The net result is everything is seen from this perspective.

I was in a meeting where an agency chief told me he didn't think what was the case five years ago, applied today. The concept was 'old-fashioned' in his words.

He is seriously deluded. Basic concepts will never change. For example, in typography, ideas like the right choice of typeface, kerning and alignment will need the same basics from now until the time when we all stop reading.

Briefing will always and forever involve a target audience description, a unique selling proposition and a tone of voice. Without that no advertisements will ever be created.

Nothing has changed. Nothing will change.

What has changed is what is now demanded from every service industry. What is the expectation from every service industry. Which can be summed up in one word.

More.

Advertising people need to be more knowledgeable, quicker on the uptake, faster to help, faster to react and way, way smarter. They need to not only know more about their clients' business, they need to know more about other business areas, so that they can bring to bear new perspectives. The old 'get the ad approved and then run after artworks' style of functioning is no longer going to be enough.

Forget servicing people, creative people are going to have to understand business and prove that they understand business on a regular basis.

And the divide and rule policy that governs most agencies needs to be thrown out of the window. Creative, servicing and planning need to work together - with a clear understanding of each others' roles and responsibilities.

Sounds simple. And most agencies will tell you they've done that.

I'm not in an agency, so I can't tell you whether that is the truth or not. All I can say is based on what I see on TV and in the press.

And I can say one thing: if they have, it doesn't show.

No comments: