Tuesday, June 16, 2020

What Should Happen To Higher Education In India?

I spent about 6 years teaching in a design college. Before that I was in and out of various colleges, teaching sessions. This included management schools, communication and design colleges and even liberal arts colleges. These are my conclusions from what I observed.
First of all, we might as well accept one fact: Indian higher education is substandard. There are a few bright spots, but on the whole, the higher educational eco-system is populated by substandard teachers who are only there for the salary, pontificating to eager-to-learn students, in under-equipped, money-making institutions.
Another truth is that students don’t really expect a fantastic education or amazing learning. The number of students who want to carry on for ‘further studies’ apart from vocational degrees like an MBA is pathetically few. There are hardly any original papers and there is hardly any original thinking.
Students really only have only one expectation from a college.
Placement.
Or, in other words, Jobs, employment, a salary.
And this is not a reflection of the mercenary, money-grubbing nature of today’s generation. Many students take loans to go to college and need to find ways to pay back the money. A salary is not a luxury – it’s essential.

The Future In My View
In my view, the Government needs to give up its stranglehold on education, particularly higher education. But it won’t.
So where are we headed?
The big brands will survive. No question of that. The IITs, IIMs, AIIMS, the St. Stephen’s, St. Xavier’s, Mt. Carmel, St. Joseph’s, NID, Delhi School of Architecture et al will continue to get students and the money will keep rolling in.
So, let’s take a look at the issues.

The Teaching Issue
What is a teacher’s job? The amount of content out there and the amount of material a student needs are completely out of proportion.
The job is to give students core concepts in the time available. So, the first part of the job is basically sifting. A professor needs to go through the reams of knowledge and research: books, websites, newspaper reports, Ph.D theses and all kinds of other matter, to figure out what your students need to know. The professors then have to put that in a form that is simple to understand, yet make sure to include enough conceptual information to justify the existence of a course in an institute of higher education.
There are ‘star’ professors today, who do precisely that. These professors sometimes see up to the entire year of students applying to attend their classes – maybe 600 or more in some cases. They have the luxury of selecting only the best and brightest.
But most professors are ordinary. They usually just rehash what they’ve been doing for the past few years and regurgitate it.
But this ordinariness cannot continue for one simple reason: on-line classes.
And what of the students who come to colleges, want to attend classes on campus?
My belief is that faculty will have to change their style of teaching.

The On-Line Challenge
The biggest game-changer in the next few years is going to be the fact that many colleges are going to be forced to change their medium of education to classes on-line. In my belief, some of the smaller institutes may have to change to a virtual campus.
This has its plus points.
Earlier, the professors were confronted with 600 students wanting to take their course, put them through a test and only allowed a limited number into the classroom. The course generally consisted of not more than 10 sessions at a maximum 3 hours of teaching. That is 30 hours of teaching per semester and professors generally use the rest of the time for writing and research, with some time put aside for evaluations.
Now, with on-line classes and pure lecture sessions, the classroom size can be 600 or more. Students could then be broken up into smaller batches that would collectively study a subject or evaluate each other. Alternatively, in any school of creative practices, each smaller group could be assigned to a junior professor or reader to evaluate. Or the students could evaluate each other and only the final product would be evaluated by the professor and a group of associates with very clear standards.
College administrations would be overjoyed by this methodology because it would increase their profitability out of all recognition. If you divide the cost of the teacher by 600 instead of 30, the margins will be enormous, even if you charge less for on-line classes.
However, ‘Education is reaching a tipping point as the gap widens between the skills delivered by the current system and those required by the digital economy,’ according to Goldman Sachs Research. This makes education ripe for disruption. “We think we’re right at the cusp of seeing the integration of technology significantly disrupt the way that education is delivered and the cost at which education can be provided,” Katherine Tait of Goldman Sachs Research explains. Tait also discusses the changing nature of today’s workforce and the evolution to lifelong learning. “We think that as the rise in automation and technology in the workplace increases, it will also drive an increase in the need to re-skill and up-skill throughout one’s career, shifting that education spend from being so concentrated in the early years of someone’s life across the length of an individual’s career.”’
Meaning, education in the first 20-odd years, where most of an individual’s time and money is spent will have to concentrate on how to train a student to be a life-long learner instead of training them on specific subject matter.
However, there are issues with online education.
The Hindu reported on some of them, when on Monday, June 1st, colleges in Kerala logged in en masse to online classes for the first time.
Apparently they had several teething issues. For a start several teachers struggled with online tools and processes. Large sections of the faculty felt they should have been trained in using such pedagogical techniques in advance because most were not familiar with the features of the videoconferencing platforms.
Attendance was also a problem. Most teachers had no clear picture of the number of students with smartphones and connectivity and therefore of attendance.
On the other hand, many students faced connectivity issues with certain colleges reporting as low as 30% attendance. Another problem was many students ran out of their daily data allocation midway through the lecture sessions. Those students who did not have good broadband connectivity were also not able to download videos with large file sizes. There were also frequent power disruptions with the onset of the monsoon. (The Hindu June 2020)
For teachers to handle online classes will take training and experience. It will take a certain amount of time to understand what is required. Replacing offline classrooms is going to be a long-term program. Faculty will need to be retrained in technology, presentation skills and in online presentation skills for this new world.
Students will also need to be conditioned to pace themselves and learn as they need. The entire focus of education on subject matter and rote learning is going to have to move towards ‘learning to learn.’
One thing that is clear however, is that the quality of teaching is going to matter more than ever.
It has to be taken into mind that it is much easier to drop out of an online class than it is to walk out of a physical classroom. In an online classroom a student can very easily switch off the sound after marking attendance while keeping her computer or smartphone on, so that, for all intents and purposes, she has attended the class.
The issue for the professor is that there will be no instant feedback from looking at faces, so changing the direction of a class; speeding up; or explaining a point that has obviously not sunk in is going to be extremely difficult.
Further, student reports on these online classes will also be on various websites. And if they reflect badly on the professors, but are well-written or just funny, they’re quite likely to go viral. That could be disastrous for the institution and the professor.
That brings us to the key issue.
Institutions will need those ‘star’ professors. The ones who know how to prune down concepts to their essentials and present their material in a way that holds a student’s interest and gives them knowledge they value and will need when they move out of the protection of academia.
Institutions of higher learning will have to learn to train their ‘star’ professors so that they can get more online registrations because of their skill in holding a class. The key must be that students will be convinced that an online class adds as much value as attending one in a lecture room.
One of the key values of a college education is the time spent on campus and often away from home. That can only be obviated by professors who add far more than the obvious value. They will need to change their way of teaching.

Changes in Styles of Teaching
The act of teaching reaches its acme of success after the lesson has been structured, after the content has been delivered and after the classroom has been organized (Hattie, 2009). The art of teaching and its major successes relate to “what happens next,” or the way in which the teacher reacts to how the student interprets, accommodates, rejects, and/or reinvents the content and skills, how the student relates and applies the content to other tasks, and how the student reacts in light of success and failure in relation to the content and methods the teacher has taught. The essence of good teaching then is that the reactions from both teacher and student are qualitatively different and better (Hattie 2009). This will be one of the key issues with online teaching, because the teacher’s ability to read a student’s reactions will be impaired.
Another way of looking at the great versus the ordinary or what makes a good teacher versus an ordinary teacher brand would be to consider the difference between schooling and education, which is analogous to the comparison between teaching and pedagogy.
This idea comes from the Ancient Greek definition of the activities of pedagogues (paidagögus) versus those of subject teachers (didáskalos).
Simplified, the concerns of didactics or didáskalos are what should be taught and learnt, in other words, the content aspect; how to teach and learn, or the aspects of transmitting and learning; to what purpose or intention something should he taught and learnt or the goal/aims aspect (Smith and Smith 2008).
Perhaps because the word ‘didactic’ in the English language is associated with dull, ‘mugging’ forms of teaching, those involved in academia tend to avoid using it. Yet, in most respects, what is talked about today as pedagogy in India is better described via the tradition of didactics (Smith 2008).
When Plato talks about pedagogues he mean ‘men who by age and experience are qualified to serve as both leaders (hëgemonas) and custodians (paidagögous)’ of children (Longenecker 1983).
The pedagogue’s roles varied, but two elements were common (Smith 2006). The first was to be an accompanist or companion – carrying books and bags, and ensuring their wards were safe. The second, and more fundamental task in relation to the boys, was to help them learn what it was to be men. This they did by a combination of example, conversation and disciplining (Smith 2006).
In short, pedagogy, traditionally was about nourishing the student and helping him to flourish (Smith and Smith 2008).
So, what comes to the fore is a focus on flourishing and of the significance of the person of the pedagogue (Smith and Smith 2008). In addition, three elements stand out about the processes of pedagogues versus teachers.
First, they are heirs to the ancient Greek process of accompanying.
Second, their pedagogy involves a significant amount of helping and caring for their students.
Third, they are engaged in what can be called, ‘bringing learning to life’ (Smith and Smith, 2008).
So, it’s obvious that pedagogues have a fundamentally different focus from more didactic, ‘subject’ teachers. Their central concern is the wellbeing of the students they are among and with. This is basically a way of working that is deeply linked to the personality of the pedagogue and his or her ability to reflect, make judgments and respond (Smith and Smith 2008). They need to be experienced and regarded by students as people who can be trusted, respected and turned to.
So pedagogy is actually about a more holistic form of practice (Cameron and Ross 2011). As Brühlmeier (2010) commented, ‘Pestalozzi has shown that there is more to [education] than attain­ing prescribed learning outcomes; it is concerned with the whole person, with their physical, mental and psychological development.’
In fact, a qualitative study by Umbach and. Wawrzynski (2005) confirms that the qualities of a pedagogue seem to make more effective teachers and more learning students.
It would be safe to assume that not all, not even most, teachers have all these qualities in the same proportions, that in fact, each teacher will be unique in her combination of these qualities. Further this is not always due to the individual teacher’s abilities or lack of them. Educational researchers have shown that not all students learn in the same way (Witkin,1973; Gregorc, 1979; Jacobs, 1990). Students are unique in their own ways, including the way they learn (Hattie, 2009).
However, in an online world, where a student has so much more control over the classroom and their own attendance, the next generation of teachers will have to combine the best qualities of a didactic and a pedagogue. Probably teachers in institutions of higher learning all over India will have to be trained to interact with their students in manner that will arouse emotions, stimulate thinking and inspire emotional responses, while imparting knowledge about facts, figures and skills. And they will have to learn to do so online.
The second advantage of the pedagogical style of teaching is that it involves creating life-long learners. Or the entire idea of nurturing “the whole person.”
If institutions are strategic and use their business-sense, they will strive to keep those professors and facilitators who do this with felicity instead of reluctantly, after training. Simply because these professors can be used as bait for students.
In fact, ‘Star’ professors will probably become increasingly valuable to an both an institution and to students. But there will also be an increasing need to communicate their skills and the value they bring.
Marketing, in other words.

Marketing Will Become Vital
This means changing the attitudes held by academics towards the marketing, advertising and branding discipline (Kirp, 2004). To many members of the faculty, marketing smacks of the commercial and debases a noble profession. It makes education ‘corporate’ and ‘managerial.’ To market a brand in higher education is often related directly to commercial advertising (Beneke, 2011).
But to sell the capabilities of the same faculty – and that will be the only benefit an institution of higher education will have to offer – they will need to rethink their marketing and branding more substantively. After all, with students attending classes on their dining tables or in their bedrooms, the kind of campus, facilities, workshops and other facilities an institution of higher education offers becomes totally irrelevant.
But most of all, they will have to keep in mind a student’s primary pre-occupation.
Jobs and salaries.

Industry Entry
If the smaller institutes want to carry on, they will have to become more industry-focused and job focused. In short, I believe all institutes will have to concentrate on vocational issues.
I’m not suggesting that all institutions of higher education will need to become vocational institutes – not by any means – however, academia will have to look beyond the narrow confines of the curriculum, to take off their leftist-tinged glasses and hook up with the real world. This means that they will need to redesign their curricula to match the requirements of industry. And that industry will have to be allowed a hand in designing curricula – an anathema for most academics.
One benefit for the institution is in exchange for giving such permission they could demand some form of subsidy.
However, given that many campuses themselves will be redundant, the only use for the subsidy would be faculty salaries and improved equipment for online classes.

Changes In Curricula
Institutes of Higher Education will need to start looking at themselves differently. Until now most of them have thought of themselves in a particular way: ‘We are a medical college,’ so we do not think about creativity or lateral thinking. ‘We are a design college,’ so business is not part of our concern. ‘We are an engineering school,’ so creative thinking is not encouraged, we want logical thinkers. And so on.
However, that will have to change. Schools will have to conceptualize and perhaps learn to teach courses that are from other disciplines. For example, course on Design Thinking will no longer be restricted to design schools. On the other side of the coin, courses on understanding business will have to become compulsory in every design school – including profit and loss, the balance sheet, cashflow and so on. Liberal Arts courses that are not related to business and cultivating a T-shaped mind, will have to become a requirement in business schools.
However, more than just different courses, I believe that Institutes of Higher Education will have to become more focused on helping make choices.

Teaching Liberal Arts
“A degree in the liberal arts prepares students not only to make a living, but also to make a life.” (Talbot and Desjardin 2016). Several academic studies have shown that studying literature, history, sociology, psychology, and other ‘soft’ subjects prepares young men and women to deal with a broad variety of life experiences – work, love, death, joy, creativity, sorrow, faith, passion, pain, injustice, disagreement, conflict, intolerance, pleasure, forgiveness, ethics, values. It will help them to deal with all the myriad choices that come with the human experience.
Studying literature for example, will teach a young person critical thinking, communication, the ability to  make choices; improve their decision-making ability; enable creative problem solving; improve abilities in self-expression; show the way to innovative research, and foster the habit of lifelong learning. These are all skills all liberal arts degrees emphasize and they are central to a great career and life (Talbot and Desjardin 2016).
A liberal arts degree prepares students for a life of learning (Talbot and Desjardin 2016) and this is an ability that is going to be required in the post-Covid era. The ability to work out of home, to come up with new, creative solutions for your home’s, neighbourhood’s, city’s, state’s, country’s and world’s problems is going to be vital.
Liberal arts create habits of the mind that facilitate a life of learning and growth, professional and personal (Talbot and Desjardin 2016). If the muscle of the mind is stronger and better prepared, a liberal arts education will churn out people who are prepared for the specialized tasks and abilities that will be needed in a VUCA (volatility, uncertainty, complexity, and ambiguity) world, which demands that you avoid traditional, outdated approaches to management and leadership, and day-to-day working. The new age human being will have to learn how to make considered, thought-out choices and decisions.
Most importantly they will have to do so quickly..
But the manner  and style of teaching liberal arts will definitely have to move from the purely didactic to the pedagogical, if students are to be given the main benefit of a liberal arts education. Institutions of higher education will need to strive to impart the kind of education that asks students to reach beyond their own experiences to see and imagine worlds different from them in time, space, and thought (Talbot and Desjardin 2016). Education and experience in multiple disciplines creates the depth and versatility people will need to successfully navigate the post-Covid VUCA world.

Institutional Focus
In the early days the IIMs each had a focus. Although the graduates were not necessarily restricted to that area, IIM-Ahmedabad supposedly specialized in Marketing, Calcutta in Finance and Bangalore in Rural Management. This didn’t seem to make much difference to the people who applied to these places, the companies who came there for placements, but it did give the institutes some sort of positioning.
Of course, higher education brands can send a strong signal to potential students about the quality and credibility of the institution (Thomson, 2002).
An example of a university that has done a solid branding job in this fashion is Columbia University (Dooley). One might well question their need for branding at all. After all, as an Ivy League school, it can easily afford to reject nine out of ten applicants, so Columbia U has all the branding it needs. However, the school still has to compete with seven other Ivy League colleges and various other peer schools to attract the most accomplished students. So, Columbia U exploits perhaps the one most important difference it has to offer.
It is the only Ivy League University in New York City, located right on Broadway.
The Columbia University website, along with and all other marketing collateral, identifies the school by its official brand name, “Columbia University in the City of New York.” It makes it clear what the promise of the University is (Dooley), so potential students may then use these cues to compare the attractiveness of a number of institutions (Utley, 2002).
To take another example, the University of Chicago’s identity is unabashedly academic (Sullivan 2012). Its curriculum emphasizes critical thinking and interdisciplinary study, and its culture revolves around intellectual discovery. The school's specific and honest proposition is resonating with a substantial, if particular, audience: Applications increased an incredible 16% from 2011 to 2012 (Sullivan, 2012). However, a student who does not wish to go to a university, “Where Fun Goes To Die” (a message students sport on their t-shirts – proving they do have a sense of humor about their brand) may consider U. Chicago’s focus a negative attribute.
A further example may be ‘rules of campus’ – whilst one institution may be respected for the level of discipline instilled in, and practiced by, its students, another institution may be perceived as being too stringent (i.e. not allowing its students the necessary freedom of expression) and thus allowing its rules to add toward its detriment.
Consider an example, Reed College (Portland, Oregon) has a positioning that can be summed up as ‘unconventional’ (Sullivan, 2012). Reed College has established itself as a highly academic school with not-so-high-maintenance tendencies. Thinking and studying are highly prized at Reed, a very small school that nonetheless produces the fourth-highest percentage of doctoral students in the U.S (Sullivan, 2012).
Sullivan (2012) quotes the example of Babson College, Massachusetts, which has successfully differentiated itself in the saturated Boston higher education market. With only 1,956 students, Babson has cultivated an all-business image and focused on entrepreneurship. It offers an accelerated business program for students who want a fast track to a career. The result is that 96% of Babson grads successfully enter the job market or graduate school within the first six months after commencement — when 53.6% of all bachelor’s degree holders under 25 are jobless or underemployed.
The smaller institution will need this sort of clear definition, which will make the niche but will also make the institution valuable to students while generating enough revenue.
At the end of the day, stronger brands hold a significant amount of appeal to high school students, who will aspire to be associated with these brands in the near future (Beneke, 2011).

In Conclusion
My view is that the smaller Indian institutions of higher education will need to undergo certain fundamental changes.
To begin with, they will need to be more focused in their offering. This means they will have to redesign their curricula to focus on key subjects that make their offering unique and valuable; collaborate with other interested parties, including people from the industry in this endeavour; include the liberal arts in their curricula no matter their focus; train their professors and staff to be pedagogues instead of didacts; change the way their campuses are designed to reflect this; make sure this style of teaching moves online as well; improve or design their libraries and online resources carefully; bring in subjects that not usually considered essential in the context of that particular institution.
Whether or not all this can be achieved, one thing is for certain.
It cannot be business as usual.