Thursday, January 17, 2013

Violence Waiting To Happen


Everybody’s talking about the way girls should be protected. They all have numerous suggestions about the way laws need to be amended, men need to be educated, how the culture needs changing.

This is right, correct and fitting. All this does need doing. We do need to change laws, change attitudes, change men.

But nobody’s talking about the kids.

Nobody’s talking about the incipient Rajus who are living on the streets of Delhi, Bombay, Bangalore, Chennai and Kolkatta. Not to mention, Nagpur, Coimbatore, Kanpur, Guwahati and a host of smaller towns.

It 0.9o Celsius right now in Delhi.

Can you imagine being some kid of 11 who has run away from home over some imagined slight? Or maybe because he was getting beaten regularly by his teacher or worse, his father?

He’s living on those streets, shivering in the cold, wondering what he needs to do to stay alive. Trying to capture any bit of warmth he can, while hiding from the police and any pederast in the neighborhood.

Can you imagine what’s going through his mind? Thoughts of revenge on the society that has treated him like this? The society that just doesn’t seem to care?

And what will happen 5 or 6 years from now when he’ll have the muscles and the body of a man – but not the emotional maturity – isn’t he another vicious rape waiting to happen?

And what exactly are we doing about him? Why is there no petition demanding that the Government pass some legislation that will help these kids grow up in decent surroundings among decent people?

We need to put pressure on the Government to look after juveniles properly. They may be delinquent, but they’re not criminals and we can’t treat them like criminals or worse. Children in remand homes are treated in an almost inhuman fashion, so it’s hardly surprising that they come out of these homes and do inhuman things.

This entire thing has to be a holistic effort.

There has to be an all-round initiative to do more than just punish rapists. We have to improve the way we treat our children.

Eventually you have to punish the monsters who commit these unspeakable crimes. If boys like the one who committed the vilest of desecrations on that poor young woman’s body are not punished, talk about justice is merely a charade. We need laws to try some juveniles as adults – and let’s not take refuge behind some UN agreement. The US and the UK have laws to try juveniles as adults for especially heinous crimes. Then watch the little psychopaths once they achieve maturity.

But simultaneously, we need laws and procedures to look after abandoned children, to treat them, counsel them and help them out of the morass in which they find themselves. Before they have the chance to become dangerous, violent, and ruthless criminals.

We need to treat the children of this country better. Stop them from getting addicted to sniffing glue, stop them from being sodomized, stop the police from treating them like little animals, stop bus-drivers from killing the wards sitting behind them, pick up runaways before they’re totally damaged by the criminal underbelly in every city . . .

To mangle Oscar Wilde, “If this is the way this nation treats our children, it doesn’t deserve to have any.”



Wednesday, January 02, 2013

The Neo-Kauravas



I read this article today. We shouldn’t be beating ourselves up so much. The horror and brutality of rape is not limited to the Indian male psyche.

It’s a problem with men.

In general.

In so-called ‘civilized’ countries like England, France and of course, the usual suspect - the United States of America.

It got me thinking.

It probably started with the entire idea of women’s liberation and the empowerment of women. But there are still Neanderthals out there who believe that women should not be strong, should not be able, competent and when they come across such women, they want to grind them down.

Rape is about power. Plain and simple.

And it’s nothing new.

So I've got a new name for them. They're not Neanderthals, they're Neo-Kauravas. Straight descendants of Dritarashtra who somehow survived Kurukshetra.

Because what Raju and Ram Singh and their little gang tried to do to that poor girl was exactly what Karna and Duryodhana tried to do to Draupadi - to debase her. To bring her down.

But they were unable to. 

And if you take Draupadi as a symbol of all women, then what Duryodhana and Dushasana could not do in Hastinapura, the Ram Singhs and Rajus of this world will not be able to do in Delhi either. Our sisters and daughters have proven that by stepping out on the streets of Delhi, braving the water cannons, lathis and tear gas this Dritarashtra of a Government has hurled at them. 

They are the winners - not the blind Manmohan Singh, his whining home minister and the harridan behind them.


But Tehelka is wrong.

The policemen they interviewed are wrong.

It’s not about sex – the Delhi police are foolish to equate rape with sex and sexual attractiveness. It won’t matter what clothes the woman wears, what her age is, or even whether she's reasonably attractive or not. In fact, she may be an old, ugly, hag and it still won't matter.

Because it’s about putting the woman in her place.

And by their lights, like Duryodhana, Dushasana and Karna, they believed her place is below men, behind men, swooning over their manly deeds. Not out there, earning money, making a life for herself, educating her brother.

So rape is about denying women the rights they have acquired after years of fighting – the right to vote, the right to work, the right to be seen as the equal of any man.

The only problem with women is that physically, they are not as strong as men. And even when they learn martial arts, they will still not be as strong as men. 

And that precisely is what the Neo-Kauravas want to prove. 

I am stronger than you are. By being strong you are weakening me. And by raping you I show how strong I am.

Rape is the only weapon the Neo-Kauravas have left. They will never win an argument on intellect. They will never be able to woo that girl with their lack of any sort of charm or ambition. They will never be able to have that sort of strong, empowered woman in their miserable, brutish lives. 

They can only debase such women. Their only solution is to use the one thing that makes them equal to the kind of men she would take for an equal.

Their penises.

And they use it savagely, violently, brutally to prove something. As if to say, “You bitch! I am in control. You are nothing.”

Tehelka says the rapes will go on. And they’re absolutely right. Just as the cops they’ve investigated are dead wrong.

The rapes are not because women dress in a particular way – it’s because they have the right to dress in that particular way. And these Neo-Kauravas, these throwbacks, these relics believe not only that women shouldn’t have the right to dress the way they choose, they shouldn't have any rights at all.

Just as for Karna, Draupadi had no right to choose the man she wanted. She had no right to a mind of her own.

For the Neo-Kauravas dressing is a symbol.

A symbol of female empowerment.

A symbol that women are out of their control. That the khaps, the uneducated, the criminal, the terminally stupid, the Neo-Kauravas will never have that educated, empowered, well-dressed, intelligent woman under their thumbs.

Why was the unknown rape victim treated so viciously and so brutally? Probably because she fought back.

She took them on. The way Draupadi took on Duryodhana and his brothers. Probably because she cursed them and probably because in some way they found out she was basically from the same class of society as they were. 

With one difference.

She had used her intelligence, her strength of will and her mind to escape the life her father had lived.

Whereas they were still stuck right there; still drivers, bus boys and gym instructors, while she was going to be a doctor. 

She was going to be respected. Maybe even rich. She was moving up in life.

She was going to be someone.

When by their lights, she should have been one of their wives. To be raped and beaten when they chose.

But for our Rape Victim, our modern-day Draupadi even that wasn’t enough.

Can you imagine? Their penises proved futile, proved too petty, too small to cow her down.

By God she must have fought them, she must have truly hit them where it hurt. She must have been as strong and outspoken as Draupadi was in cursing the Kauravas and their ineffectual king.

So they had to use iron rods.

Can there be anything more pathetic and contemptible than those boys? They had nothing that could bring her back down to their level. Not even that little piece of flesh between their legs.

So they used iron rods.


Sorry boys. Sorry Neo-Kauravas everywhere. Women have wiggled out after centuries of repression and they’re never going back.
  
For the Neo-Kauravas the only thing that’ll work is Judge Dredd sort of justice – immediate, vicious and irrevocable.

Above all quick. The battle of the Kurukshetra was over in 17 days.

But finally, the men of India and the world have to decide what they want to be. On which side they will stand.

On the side of Draupadi and the Pandavas? (They had God on their side remember?) A conniving, scheming God, who helped them win through duplicity and deceit. 

But nonetheless God.

Or on the side of molesters and would-be rapists like the Kauravas? Who, despite their competence, despite the Herculean efforts of Bhishma, Karna and Dhronacharya, lost their wealth, their kingdom and their lives.

And like Judas they have been damned for all time.

We need to work, not just on justice, but on further empowerment. Because women are as competent, able and ambitious as men. There's only difference between us.

A penis.

And that's nothing to be so hugely proud of.

So choose. 

Neo Kaurava? Or Pandava?



Teacher Wisdom

What do I try to do while teaching? Robert Frost said it best so many decades ago.