Saturday, December 29, 2012

Villain and Victim



A seventeen-year-old accident-waiting-to-happen was the main instigator of the rape and murder that’s galvanized India and enraged students barely older than him.

But because of his age he’s going to get away with it.  

Scot-free.

He is a monster. But he’s not going to get the retribution due to a monster.

But the thing is that he was a criminal already. Small-time at the time, nothing consequential, but I bet he carried a venomous grouse against society.

They say he ran away from home at some ridiculously young age. He has been living off his ‘wits’ on the streets of Delhi for the last so many years.

The driver and the young ‘un’s mentor was a known sexual predator. He was also known to be violent and a proclaimed offender.

There are so many questions that need to be answered.

For example, how did those two known misfeasors get possession of a bus? Especially one that was supposed to be a school bus? Can you imagine what could have happened with those two men and a load of schoolchildren?

Is there any concept of a background check for the men who get behind the wheel of what amounts to a 6-tonne lethal weapon?

There’s something fundamentally wrong with a system that allows a sexual deviant to drive a public transport vehicle. For children no less.

Equally there’s something vitally flawed about a system that allows a minor to roam the streets of our Capital living by his wits.  

No matter how vicious and undisciplined he was, no matter that his parents wanted nothing to do with the little thug, shouldn’t the police have pulled him off the streets and put him into a remand home? Instead it’s quite likely that the only policeman the boy ever saw either raped him, or beat him and demanded hafta from him.

Yet, he needed an alternative to the kind of squalid life he must have led out on the streets. On the other hand, it is quite possible that even a remand home would have served no purpose unless he was given some kind of counseling because it’s evident that he was already a little psychopath.

And that’s another question: is there any system to rehabilitate these budding monsters?

Come to think about it if he hadn’t been arrested, he might quite possibly have ended up as one of those anonymous fatalities of a cold winter’s night in Delhi that you read about, sigh and forget.

Yet another question. What are the ‘authorities’ going to do with that psychopathic killer after they’ll be forced to release him in three years?

Is he going to be allowed to roam the streets of Delhi? And what happens if he decides that Delhi is too ‘hot’ for him and goes to Mumbai or Chennai or Bangalore instead? How are the police going to keep track of him?

And how many more of his type of psychopath is scrounging around our cities? Serving tea at small restaurants, being paid a pittance for 18 hours of hard labor a day, and to add to it a touch of pederasty from the owner, his friends, his customers not to mention your friendly neighborhood policeman. How many more young boys are developing a rage that’s going to explode and destroy a young woman’s life? How many young boys are growing up believing that a criminal is a hero and heroes get away with everything?

How many boys are like the young psychopath who led the attack on the young lady: both victim and villain?

Sunday, December 23, 2012

The Rarest Of The Rare


My lawyer cousin might be able to answer this, but I’m thoroughly confused by this entire ‘rarest of the rare’ thing.

What exactly constitutes the ‘rarest of the rare’?

Every other day, we hear about some Pakistan-trained jackass sliming his way over the border and using automatic weapons and his training to murder dozens of people in Kashmir. He too is normally dealt with by soldiers. He too normally kills an army officer before being killed.

Sounds kind of everyday, doesn’t it?

However, when the same sort of miscreant comes to Bombay – sorry Mumbai – the identical sequence of events becomes, (abracadabra!) the ‘rarest of the rare.’

Wouldn’t that sound ridiculous to any right-thinking human being?

Okay. Rape.

A woman gets raped every 42 minutes in India.

Every forty-two minutes. While you’re reading this, a woman is being raped somewhere in our benighted country.

That’s ghastly and a real reflection on how the Laws of Manu have become a part of our society’s behavior. It is evil, dastardly and deserves condemnation.

Yet, if that is true, what exactly makes what happened in Delhi, ‘the rarest of the rare?’

Okay, this horrific incident was more brutal than some, but it was also the same thing – a penis or some other foreign object was inserted into an unwilling woman’s vagina. I’m sorry if that sounds clinical, but isn’t that approximately how the law would phrase it?

Lawyer cousin, what do you think?

There was a case about thirty years ago when some policeman tried to rape a young – male – student outside Delhi University. Luckily, as the over-sexed officer of the law pulled his pants down, the student escaped. But what if he had been successful – would that have qualified as the ‘rarest of the rare’ or would it have not applied because the rape victim was male?

How does one rape qualify to be more ‘rare’ than the next?

Does the poor girl have to die?

Does she have to be so physically damaged that living will be difficult, not to say impossible for her?

But wait a minute. Isn’t that the case with any woman who is raped?

Does any daughter, wife or mother deserve to be counted as lesser in that her rape doesn’t qualify as the ‘rarest of the rare?’

The Supreme Court in its wisdom has decided that only the ‘rarest of the rare’ deserves the death penalty, which is fine as far as it goes. But perhaps the legislature now needs to spend time trying to outline what constitutes the ‘rarest of the rare.’ Perhaps they need to put aside their preoccupation with politics as usual and their obsession with fattening their own bank accounts and do something that makes the Indian State seem more civilized.

But I suppose that if Parliament actually did some work that would qualify as the ‘rarest of the rare’ in itself.

Anger And Denial


Has something changed in the recent past? Why are people suddenly reacting to events that are, though grotesque and soul-scarring, not that unusual?

The killing of children - by what amounts to another child - in a school in the USA. It's not the first time and since it happened again within a few days of the first happening, it's very doubtful that it will be the last time either.

However, 'this time is different' says CNN. This time the lawmakers in the US are actually activated to do something about this problem they have.

A girl raped in Delhi - admittedly it was a little more brutal than previously - but again nothing new. But this time you have students and young women from all over Delhi marching on India Gate and Raisinha Hill. 

The only difference is that in beautiful, vibrant, Incredible India - unlike in the United States - our politicians don't seem to care what the people think.

I have to say Manmohan Singh is amazing. Despite the outrage, despite the anger, despite the huge rise in public sentiment, the man (wimp?) hasn't bothered to step out of his little "I have integrity" cocoon to address the country. To reassure women all around the country, "Yes we are going to do something concrete." Instead, he is cowering like a rabbit in his hole, which, unfortunately, is also known as the Prime Minister's residence. He has no integrity - he may not be financially corrupt, but the man has no decency, no integrity and no right to sit in the chair that he occupies.

Think Mr. Singh – you have daughters. Daughters who studied at Jawaharlal Nehru University, who, given your renowned ‘financial probity’ probably caught a bus home from Munikra. That’s the same place where that unfortunate young lady caught the bus that contained the gargoyles that raped her.

What if it had been one of your daughters? 

Would you have opened your mouth and reacted then? 

Or would you have still kept the silence of a fundamentally indecent and morally corrupt man?

And Rahul Gandhi! Well son, think a bit. 

What if it was Priyanka out there? 

What if it was her - your sister going for a movie, then getting on a bus to come home. Pretty girl, nice figure - fair game for the animals out there. 

Animals, my friend, that you refuse to condemn.

We talk about the terror that is being planted in our country by our worthy neighbor. What about the terrorists spawned in every mother’s womb? What about the terrorists spawned by those doting Indian mothers who only seem to fawn and deify their sons? None of the rapists were from the ‘minority community’ – they all, without exception, carried good Hindu names.

It’s not just laws. 

It’s not just castration or the threat of a rope that’s going to stop these inhuman monsters from damaging more women. 

It’s not going to be something legislated in Parliament.

It’s attitudes that need changing. Attitudes to women. Attitudes that make women chattel. Attitudes that women themselves promote.

India needs to change. India needs to understand that this is just not acceptable behavior. No ‘world power’ will ever behave like this.

We're home to far too many monsters. 

Starting with those who sit in Parliament. 

Those we elect.

Scream that out! Understand that! Because if we don't change the Chautalas, the Kalmadis, the Bhanots and the other animals, those further down the economic scale, but no further up the evolutionary scale will never change their ways or understand concepts like common decency.

And that's what we lack.

Common decency.

The decency to obey the laws of the road. The decency not to spit wherever we want to. The decency not throw our garbage where others have to step around them. The decency to stop your car or motorcycle to allow school-children to cross the road.

We're in denial. Unless, we, the great middle-class, learn to change our behavior, nothing is going to change.

And all the anger amounts to spitting into a hurricane of denial.

Thursday, December 06, 2012

6 Things I’ve learned From My Favorite Teachers


Let's start with Subbu. Mr. Subramaniam was my favorite teacher at Rishi Valley. He was also my housemaster. This was way back in 1972, but what I remember most of all about him was quite simple.

He trusted us.

Yes we were a bunch of rowdy boys. We were unruly. We were undisciplined.

But he trusted us.

And most of us tried to justify that trust.

So that's the first thing.

Trust Your Students
And They'll Prove Themselves
Worthy of Your Trust


The second thing he did was believe in us. He believed we could do things and made us believe we could do things too.

I was bad at math before Rishi Valley, but Subbu gave us a paper that had 80 marks with easy questions and 20 marks for the more difficult part. He then promised us 4 extra marks if we got everything right in the 20-mark portion. I got everything right and he was as good as his word.

I got 104%! In maths! For the first and only time in my life I actually cracked a maths exam.

That's the next learning.

Believe In Your Students


The next teacher who inspired me was Alan Samuel, who taught us English at St. James’ School, Calcutta.

He was a total misfit. He wore the most amazingly colored clothes, (yellow shirt, green trousers and a green tie – bright green and bright yellow). He had hippy-inspired hair and played bass guitar in a rock-n-roll band at a 5-star hotel.

Unfortunately, he didn’t teach us all that often, (he spent most of his time goofing off, playing guitar in class, making us singing songs, or simply not turning up) but when he did, he was miraculous.

The first thing I remember is the way he ‘taught’ us Macbeth. Instead of doing it the typical way, he asked us all to keep quiet (“Do me a favor guys. Just keep quiet and listen to me for two days, cool?”).

Then he read Macbeth out aloud to us.

In different voices.

Playing each role.

Like a sort of hippy Lawrence Olivier.

At the end of it, Macbeth was embedded in my memory. I knew it end-to-end, word for word.

The next was Ode To Autumn (Keats). One stanza goes;

“Who hath not seen thee oft amid thy store?
“Sometimes whoever seeks abroad may find
“Thee sitting careless on a granary floor,
“Thy hair soft-lifted by the winnowing wind;”

I can still remember how he described it, “You know those chicks from Pratt’s man? How they walk along?” And then (he had extremely long hair) he walked up and down in front of the class, bouncing his hair.

Impossible to forget.

From him I learned:

Drama Is
Part And Parcel of Teaching

Possibly the most important part of teaching. It embeds your thinking into your students.

The next teacher I remember is John Mason. My principal. Again his methodology was to have faith in us. But he matched it with a knack for discipline. He also had the ability to read his boys and pinpoint their talent and what would suit them.

He’s the one who told my father to let me do English Literature in college. I think that if I had to do commerce I would have jumped off a roof.

From Mason I learnt you need to understand your students and empathize with them. In sum;

Know Your Students

In college there were two widely divergent teachers; Eunice D’Souza and Nisha D’Cunha.

Eunice was amazing for her sheer breadth of knowledge. She knew every critic, she could interpret them and she was amazingly erudite.

That’s one thing I learnt.

Know More


Know more than enough.

Know what you’re talking about – backwards and forwards.

Know your matter.

The second thing I learnt was from something she never did.

Eunice D’Souza wouldn’t even listen to a question that came from a source that she didn’t like or find acceptable.

And answer that question?

Surely you jest.
  
And that’s the second thing I learnt. Listen to your students and accept a differing point of view. Try to rebut it if you can, if you can’t see how it makes sense and if you need to, incorporate that argument into your next lecture, seminar or workshop.

If not, like Eunice, you end up being thought of as intellectually outstanding and amazingly erudite. But, you will also be seen as narrow-minded and unable to accept anybody else’s opinion.

Which made certain anybody with a modicum of intelligence would lose respect for her.

I know I did.

So, to repeat;

Accept A
Varying Point Of View

Nisha D’Cunha, on the other hand, was much less about a sharp intellect. She was more about emotions and feelings. She explained literature with emotions, rather than the intellectual sharpness of a Eunice D’Souza.

In short, Nisha enlivened Literature and made it more alive. 

She was also willing to accept an opinion that was directly contradictory to her own – whoever it came from. I used to sometimes answer questions in direct contradiction to her opinions - just to irritate her. And if the answer was well-argued, she would accept it - even give me top marks for it. 

Wonderful woman. Wonderful teacher.

And that’s what she taught me that your students are entitled to have their different opinions and you can both be right.

Students May Have
Different Opinions From You

Of course, my bosses also taught me so much. Mohan Menon, Mohammed Khan, Sandhya Honavar. Suresh Mullick . . . but you can’t really call them teachers, I suppose.

In the end, I suppose it's all about getting the good habits of your favorite teachers and ignoring the bad habits. Take in the good. Ignore the bad. An old-fashioned thought, but good teachers do marry the most old-fashioned principles.