Friday, November 12, 2010

Your customer isn’t always right

Your consumer may be your wife, but she’s not the sun, moon and stars. She is not the last word on branding. In fact, her opinion may cause you to arrive at entirely the wrong branding decisions.

That’s why a consumer’s opinion is only one input – albeit an important one – that you must use to build a brand identity.

Your advertising agency will probably add the fact that your brand must consider the competition – which again is true, but it’s still only part of the story.

So what else is there?

The answer is for one, your own company’s DNA; its philosophical underpinnings and the history that govern your day-to-day dealings.

What kind of company are you?

Are you an aggressive, hard-going, even abrasive company? Then, a brand strategy that emphasizes what a warm, generous, giving brand you are is quite simply ludicrous.

Your people will not be able to deliver on the ‘warm, generous and giving’ when their training, evaluation and inclination – and probably their recruitment – is based on entirely the opposite standards.

So, although there is one customer-facing area – advertising and communication – in which you can communicate your brand promise, in most other customer-facing areas the brand will fail miserably to deliver.

Instead of positioning a brand from that company as being soft and mushy, it would make a lot more sense to take up a position in the area of ‘we are extremely aggressive – on your behalf’. That way, when customers meet your people, they come in expecting aggressive, hard-going, even abrasive behaviour.

Even when your brand is an FMCG and the theory is that the company’s values have no relevance, there has to be a match.
If the Company’s philosophy and the brand’s values do not match, the brand will behave in an inconsistent manner – which disconcerts consumers.

Take an example of two FMCG companies. One has a philosophy of bringing ‘demonstrably better’ products to the consumer. The other comes from the point of view of a trader – buy-low, sell-high.

If this is the essential genetic deposition of the company, a brand from the ‘trader’ company is unlikely to be a superior product. So, attempting to position a brand from the ‘trader’ company as one that provides a ‘better than’ experience would be a non-starter.

A Company that is genetically predisposed to creating ‘demonstrably superior’ products, on the other hand, is more likely to sustain a brand that promises superior products.

In sum, brand must incorporate a company’s strengths and acknowledge its weaknesses.

The second aspect that is often left in a sort of limbo is the environment – nobody bothers to answer the question, ‘how will the brand behave in the light of environmental changes?’

They say that a cell-phone is basically a small computer with a radio attached. If that’s so, how will all the cell-phone brands work in an era when there will be a rapid convergence of communication, entertainment and information into one, small, hand-held device? Will that area be dominated by cell-phone companies or computer companies?

Apple – a computer company – has already entered the fray with their iPhone and caused a level of consternation.

Who’s next? HP? IBM? Acer? Lenovo?

So how should Nokia and Ericsson, Samsung and LG react – both in product terms and as brands? As of now, cell-phone brands seem to ignoring the environmental threat of convergence as brands, concentrating on entertainment and fashion instead of converging technologies. This is despite the fact that all these companies have access to the same technology as Apple.

Another example is of passenger liner brands. It took them almost fifty years to adjust to the idea that a ship is no longer an acceptable means of transport – it is just too slow. The passenger liner brands of today are entertainment brands – but it took the death of several passenger liner brands and the grounding of several ships before Royal Norwegian sailed into profitability.

Making sure a brand incorporates the ability to adapt to the changes in its environment, will inevitably lead to a stronger and less vulnerable brand.

Should a brand incorporate the consumer’s point of view?

Of course.

No question about it.

Should a brand incorporate a reaction to the competition – be competitive, in other words?

Undoubtedly.

However, the opinion of your consumer – who may or may not be your wife – is only one factor among many to be considered.

No comments: