Monday, November 08, 2010

How retail killed the garment brand

Most garment marketers know that all men have a portfolio of brands in their cupboards. They also undoubtedly know that men use different garments for different purposes.

However, their positioning and branding doesn’t seem to reflect that knowledge.

And in my view, that’s the core reason why most Indian middle-market garment brands are not really strong brands.
Instead, today, if you look at it carefully, most Indian garment brands are actually retail brands.

To understand how and why this happened, it may be necessary to look at history a bit.

Formal branded garments began with Zodiac. Park Avenue wasn’t really a garment brand – it was more of a retail brand with Raymond’s trying to use some of the space they had on hand.

Zodiac had no real brand positioning – it was just meant to represent a ‘male’ shirt with advertising showing a rather hirsute male. The same advertisement ran for years.

The game was changed drastically by Madura Garments who launched Louis Philippe and Van Heusen. Both these brands had a distinct imagery – Louis Philippe, with ‘The Upper Crest’ was very clearly for high-end, sophisticated men – the board room if you like. Van Heusen was the ‘corporate’ brand and had a clear image with first ‘underline your presence’ and then ‘power-dressing’ – Vice-Presidents and Senior Management in terms of target audience.

Madura Garments followed that up with Allen Solly, which was aimed at the more ‘artistic’ and right-brain oriented professionals – architects, designers, the ‘communications elite’. Finally, they completed their palette with Peter England, the good value corporate shirt – aimed at the lower level executives, the clerks and so on.

Okay. So all was well.

Then, Madura Garments, the biggest player got bitten by the retail bug. So, Allen Solly, Louis Philippe and Van Heusen were sold together under the roof of Planet Fashion. All the brands were clubbed together in one environment. Naturally, the distinctions between the retail spaces of the brands were blurred.

But what followed should have been preceded by huge red signals from the concerned parties; the only branding devices left – the actual garments and the advertising – became blurred.

Every shirt brand seemed to be willing to use some fancy international location and international models – the earlier differentiation between the brands was slowly, but inevitably eroded.

Then came the entire problem of stock clearance. A boon to every red-blooded, Indian male who so fervently believes a penny saved is a penny earned. The thinking was simple, ‘Anyway, I’m not picky about which brand I wear – so I’ll buy the shirt that’s on sale or at the Factory Price Store closest to me.’

The net result is that today, there is no difference between any of the brands, barring, possibly Louis Philippe. Instead the consumer is faced with a glorious, undifferentiated blur. So, you’ve no reason to relate any brand to any time, usage, personality, philosophy or way of life.

You just go out to buy ‘a shirt’ – any shirt, for any purpose. Whereas earlier, you might have insisted on wearing an Allen Solly if you’re in the creative department of an advertising agency, today, you could equally well go with a Louis Philippe, a Van Heusen, an Indigo Nation, a Scullers or even a Peter England.

It makes no difference.

This sounds good to the factory manager and warehouse keeper, but should make no sense to a marketer.

So what’s the solution?

In my belief, if they want to sell more garments, manufacturers need to stop chasing the dream of the ‘retail revolution’ and return to the basics of sharply differentiated targeting and branding to those targets.

And the weird part of it is that this is not difficult to do.

In my belief, brand is behavior. It's not communication.

So, the first step would be look at your product portfolio. The decisions are basically governed by which product belongs to which brand.

A red, brushed-silk shirt should go to Allen Solly or Scullers, regardless of how expensive it is. A clean crisp white cotton shirt goes to Louis Philippe or Indigo Nation, a blue pin-stripe goes into Van Heusen. The plain, inexpensive fabrics and cuts should go to John Miller and Peter England.

You won’t get a bright red Van Heusen, just as you won’t get staid, sober and corporate in Allen Solly.

The next step would be to differentiate the retail environment in which each brand is sold. Carefully decide the colors, the flooring, the scent in the air, the music, even the kind of salesmen and what they wear.

Finally, you need focused communication.

Obviously this starts with preferably well-written advertising – as opposed to well photographed and well art-directed advertising. This would be bolstered by events and sponsorships that make sense for each brand. For example, it would make sense for Van Heusen to be a part of corporate training programs and seminars, Louis Philippe to be around corporate golf events and for Allen Solly to be essential at music and cultural happenings.

Of course, these are only a few of the possible existing positioning routes possible – there are many more. But it would require a scientific process and a carefully-thought-out brand design. But it can be done.

The question is, do garment manufacturers and their professional managers know this?

Awkward question, that.

No comments: