Apparently one of my novels won’t work in this ‘publishing climate’ according to one of the agents I mailed.
I've heard this before and I have a question.
What climate is that?
The novel in question has a pretty much universal plot ie:
boy meets princess, loses princess who goes off and marries large, hairy, evil villain who treats her abominably, boy finds ordinary girl, gets married, has babies then loses ordinary girl though horrible circumstance, meanwhile princess escapes from villain, shortly afterwards boy meets princess again, they fall in love, princess beats up villain (that’s the twist) and boy and princess live happily ever after.
Pretty near universal any way you look at it, I thought. Nearly Tolstoy.
Is it well-written?
I think so.
Is it psychologically accurate?
Yep – according to a friend of mine who works at India’s leading psychiatric hospital it is.
Is it below the 1,25,000 word limit?
Yes it is ladies and gentlemen.
But it doesn’t work in ‘this publishing climate’.
The novel is about an incredibly brave woman, who despite being terrorized by her brutal husband escapes and makes her life again.
If that doesn’t work what does?
But you know what?
I don't think the 'publishing climate' has anything to do with the price of fish in Colaba.
I think the rejection is because here's an Indian author who has the infernal gall to write a book that isn't about exotic India. No backwaters of Kerala. No weirdness in the Western Ghats. No hash in Hastinapur.
I've chosen to write what I write. So I guess I'll have to keep writing until one day somebody decides that the writing is important - not the usual stereotypes of what an Indian should write.
Am I whining?
Yes. Quite probably.
I've heard this before and I have a question.
What climate is that?
The novel in question has a pretty much universal plot ie:
boy meets princess, loses princess who goes off and marries large, hairy, evil villain who treats her abominably, boy finds ordinary girl, gets married, has babies then loses ordinary girl though horrible circumstance, meanwhile princess escapes from villain, shortly afterwards boy meets princess again, they fall in love, princess beats up villain (that’s the twist) and boy and princess live happily ever after.
Pretty near universal any way you look at it, I thought. Nearly Tolstoy.
Is it well-written?
I think so.
Is it psychologically accurate?
Yep – according to a friend of mine who works at India’s leading psychiatric hospital it is.
Is it below the 1,25,000 word limit?
Yes it is ladies and gentlemen.
But it doesn’t work in ‘this publishing climate’.
The novel is about an incredibly brave woman, who despite being terrorized by her brutal husband escapes and makes her life again.
If that doesn’t work what does?
But you know what?
I don't think the 'publishing climate' has anything to do with the price of fish in Colaba.
I think the rejection is because here's an Indian author who has the infernal gall to write a book that isn't about exotic India. No backwaters of Kerala. No weirdness in the Western Ghats. No hash in Hastinapur.
I've chosen to write what I write. So I guess I'll have to keep writing until one day somebody decides that the writing is important - not the usual stereotypes of what an Indian should write.
Am I whining?
Yes. Quite probably.
No comments:
Post a Comment