I was invited to
NIMHANS the other day to a seminar on the problems of alcohol - the aim was to
make recommendations regarding an alcohol policy for the Government of India.
I was asked to talk
about alcohol advertising. Of which I have done a lot. Over ten years of
working on UB and McDowell, industriously laboring to make Vijay Mallya richer.
So I made this fun
presentation, which was based on the idea that alcohol is next to impossible to
ban because it is fun, easy and cheap. I added a little serious bit by telling
them how alcohol companies circumvent the regulations against advertising
alcohol by launching surrogate products - which are then advertised.
It doesn't matter if
they're loss-making products.
What matters is that
they can advertise the brand.
Getting Serious
I had fun making the
presentation, in fact, it was all just fun and games. Lighthearted stuff.
At first.
But after listening to
others talk over two days, I realized that alcohol is an issue in our
country. And there are people who are seriously concerned about it.
I was thinking about
the government's policy on alcohol advertising versus my fun/easy/cheap
mantra.
Fun
There is a concerted
effort to remove the 'fun' element from alcohol by a variety of legal and
seemingly over-puritanical measures. Closing bars by 11, stopping dancing
girls/live dancing, active policing against drunk driving and so on.
However, the most
'fun' is actually evoked by one simple factor: communication. By this I would
not only include advertising, events and PR, but also Point of Sale and most
important, packaging.
Easy
By 'easy' I meant
three things: easy to make, easy to sell and easy to consume.
Easy to make: there's
nothing much you can do to change basic chemistry. A person can make a cheap
and cheerful wine in his home. Of course, making it far less simple to make officially
would be a far easier to implement. But as the experience in the USA and closer
to home, Gujarat, shows total prohibition is a recipe for disaster.
Easy to sell:
there are thousands of liquor shops all over the country. There is so much
money in the business that you wold find it very difficult to shut it down. As
the evidence of Delhi shows, people don't even care about what brand they get
as long as they get their liquor.
Wait a minute. That's
not really true. When the Government shops in Delhi insisted on providing only
certain brands of liquor, people went over the border to Gurgaon or Noida to
get their favorite tipple. They cared enough to get their own preferred
brands.
Okay. Moving on.
Easy to consume: there
are bottles in every size. If you are broke, you can buy a small bottle and
shoot it down so that it hits you hard. Liquor is available at the shops for
instant consumption - so that a drinker can hit his favorite shop, have two
tots and move on without worrying any more about it. (Except now that the
police have gotten serious about punishing drunk drivers).
Cheap
Governments all over
India have been working assiduously to make alcohol more expensive. Excise,
sales tax, customs duty, corporate taxes, etcetera.
That doesn't seemed to
have changed anything other than the said governments' coffers, which
have been seriously enriched by a certain branch of the population's addiction.
Unfortunately, those
trying to limit liquor sales are dealing with a product that is price-agnostic,
demand-agnostic, shortage-agnostic and even to a large extent,
quality-agnostic.
But for a certain part
it is not brand-agnostic.
So in my view, if you
want to cut down the amount of alcohol consumed in our country my solution would
be simply this.
Abolish brands.
Types of drinkers
At the seminar, I
learnt that there are actually three types of drinkers - they sort of overlap
in a continuum and one category of drinker can easily slip into another, but the basic
divisions are as follows.
Social Drinkers: people
who enjoy their drinks and know how to limit themselves. They can stick to
their one or two drinks and be happy. Personally, I have nothing against people like this. There's a live and let live vibe here.
Hard Drinkers: these
are people who have less control. Their one drink becomes four and five and
they lose control , drive drunk, get into fights, create a ruckus and become a
public nuisance. The intervention is generally therapy.
Alcoholics:
these are the addicts. This is a mental illness. The doctors even tell me it's
genetic. It can only be handled by therapy and medication. This has to be left
to the professionals, the people at NIMHANS. It is not something that should
concern the abolitionists. Their drinking is a disease and it has to be treated
like a disease.
The drinkers any
anti-alcohol measures can address are basically the first two
categories. It can do nothing for the third. Unredeemed or untreated alcoholics
will find their liquor in any way they can.
Abolishing Brands
So how should the
Government handle the first two categories? In my view they should start with
continuing the existing ban on advertising.
But there should be
more.
There should be a ban
on all forms of branding.
And it should start
with labels.
The Government of
India must ban all labels. The only liquor available would be presented to
consumers in identical bottles with a plain white label stating whatever form
of liquor it is; whiskey, rum, gin, vodka and so on. Maybe, if they want to be
really nice, they should allow the name of the maker to be on the label. But
the names should be regulated. All brand names should be written in the same
typeface, a plain, very non-communicative typeface; Times Roman, Arial,
something like that. The size should also be regulated; it should not be more
than a certain percentage of the label.
There should be a
total ban on sponsorships: no football teams, no IPL, no horse races, no
cricket tournaments. Nothing. Not even in the name of the corporation making
the liquor. No McDowell or United Breweries Derby.
The final step would
be to spend substantial sums of money on anti-liquor advertising. It would not
talk about the damage liquor does to you, your family, your body or the sort of negativity that most strategies use.
The only thing it
should do is to de-hip liquor.
Meaning the advertising should concentrate on
how to totally ruin the image of liquor as a brand. It should emphasize that liquor does not make you
hepper, it does not make you cool, it does not make you smarter, more
attractive to women or all the other promises that liquor brands use to lull
with you into buying and drinking more of their product.
What it does do is to
make you sloppy, out of control, intemperate, choleric and generally a
totally uncool person.
This will not
eliminate the attraction to the alcoholics, but at least it will prevent effect two sorts of people. The consumers who think drinking is a sophisticated thing to do. And youngsters who think it's a cool thing to do.
All this will do nothing for people who drink to get drunk. And nothing at all for an alcoholic.
But if it stops some kid from becoming an alcoholic surely it is a good thing?
All this will do nothing for people who drink to get drunk. And nothing at all for an alcoholic.
But if it stops some kid from becoming an alcoholic surely it is a good thing?
4 comments:
You write: "Alcoholics: these are the addicts. This is a mental illness. The doctors even tell me it's genetic." Fair enough. You conclude by writing “but if it stops some kid from becoming an alcoholic surely its a good thing”.
Are you saying advertising causes Alcoholics? I don’t think so.
Do away with liquor branding?? IMHO, a totally impractical thing to do. My guess is that (I haven't researched this) there is more unbranded toddy and country liquor sold in this country in one year, than all the IMFLs put together in ten years.
Also, by the 'un-branding' logic, has the consumption of commodities such as dal, rice whatever (which obviously are not branded) ever been low? And as for the 'fun' part that comes because of branding, is it fun to eat a samosa, burst a few balloons and blow paper trumpets at a birthday party? Using all un-branded stuff? I think it still is :-)
Just my two bits...
Rajan Nair
Actually if you go by what the excise commissioner of Karnataka and the wonks at NIMHANS say, the Government has managed to control toddy (except for one district in Karnataka where it is a religious ritual) and other country liquors - with a bunch of different methods. So, although the NIMHANS guys actually believe that country liquors are healthier than IMFLs, they haven't' been able to persuade the Government not to ban it because it's easier to collect money on IMFL rather than something somebody makes on a tree.
I also believe that alcohol consumption is a continuum. It is genetic and a mental illness, but it won't manifest itself if the person has no opportunity to taste liquor.
If you never start trying a drug - whatever the drug - you will never get the chance to get addicted to it.
Post a Comment