Sunday, December 23, 2012

The Rarest Of The Rare


My lawyer cousin might be able to answer this, but I’m thoroughly confused by this entire ‘rarest of the rare’ thing.

What exactly constitutes the ‘rarest of the rare’?

Every other day, we hear about some Pakistan-trained jackass sliming his way over the border and using automatic weapons and his training to murder dozens of people in Kashmir. He too is normally dealt with by soldiers. He too normally kills an army officer before being killed.

Sounds kind of everyday, doesn’t it?

However, when the same sort of miscreant comes to Bombay – sorry Mumbai – the identical sequence of events becomes, (abracadabra!) the ‘rarest of the rare.’

Wouldn’t that sound ridiculous to any right-thinking human being?

Okay. Rape.

A woman gets raped every 42 minutes in India.

Every forty-two minutes. While you’re reading this, a woman is being raped somewhere in our benighted country.

That’s ghastly and a real reflection on how the Laws of Manu have become a part of our society’s behavior. It is evil, dastardly and deserves condemnation.

Yet, if that is true, what exactly makes what happened in Delhi, ‘the rarest of the rare?’

Okay, this horrific incident was more brutal than some, but it was also the same thing – a penis or some other foreign object was inserted into an unwilling woman’s vagina. I’m sorry if that sounds clinical, but isn’t that approximately how the law would phrase it?

Lawyer cousin, what do you think?

There was a case about thirty years ago when some policeman tried to rape a young – male – student outside Delhi University. Luckily, as the over-sexed officer of the law pulled his pants down, the student escaped. But what if he had been successful – would that have qualified as the ‘rarest of the rare’ or would it have not applied because the rape victim was male?

How does one rape qualify to be more ‘rare’ than the next?

Does the poor girl have to die?

Does she have to be so physically damaged that living will be difficult, not to say impossible for her?

But wait a minute. Isn’t that the case with any woman who is raped?

Does any daughter, wife or mother deserve to be counted as lesser in that her rape doesn’t qualify as the ‘rarest of the rare?’

The Supreme Court in its wisdom has decided that only the ‘rarest of the rare’ deserves the death penalty, which is fine as far as it goes. But perhaps the legislature now needs to spend time trying to outline what constitutes the ‘rarest of the rare.’ Perhaps they need to put aside their preoccupation with politics as usual and their obsession with fattening their own bank accounts and do something that makes the Indian State seem more civilized.

But I suppose that if Parliament actually did some work that would qualify as the ‘rarest of the rare’ in itself.

3 comments:

Stonethrowers Rants said...

Rarest of rare is continually defined, redefined, modified with changing social mores by the Courts.

Broadly, judgements by Courts are law. Hence, it is not normally necessary for the Parliament to jump in and change things around. The concept of RoR is continually moulded anyway.

On another point, rape is one offence. If the rapist also kills or causes grievous hurt then he would have to face more than one charge for which the punishment may well be death.

Criminal law in India by itself is perfectly adequate and satisfactory. The problem is in its administration, the speed of administration, the quality of administration and the investigation. We need to fix all this, not change the law.

Stonethrowers Rants said...

One more point. The outrage is justified but most people miss the point, or club together the many facts.

Please do bear in mind that the girl lost her intestines due to the gruesome attack on her with iron rods. Even if they had not raped her, these would be equally serious.

Pandi said...

Thanks for that clarification. The idea that the courts will decide what is the 'rarest of the rare' is far more comforting than the idea of Parliament making that decision.