Thursday, September 27, 2012

Plus Ca Change, Plus C'est La Meme Chose


Every generation of advertising guys thinks the next generation is all rubbish. This is axiomatic.
However, advertising, like everything else is subject to Sturgeon’s Law, which declares, “90% of everything is crap.”
I was sitting in front of my television yesterday, watching a Hindi program and here’s a list of the TV commercials I saw. And what I thought they showed about the future of Indian advertising.
Samsung Champ Deluxe – predictable to the last microsecond. Boy lures a bunch of his ‘pals’ under an arch for a photograph and his real pals drench them and he takes photograph. Wow! Totally original, a real creative idea. Sorry guys. Just sarcasm. It was not even a decent demo. Just an ordinary ho-hum snooze of a TV commercial.
And if Samsung was bad, next came horrid. A commercial for a Limca Contest. And now comes the oh-so-very-predictable idea. The first resort of every hack copywriter in the country. Wow! I’ve nailed it boss! Let’s use a Celebrity (yes, with a capital ‘C’). Let’s use Karishma Kapoor! Let’s go boys and girls, I’ve always wanted to meet that hot broad.
This was followed by Nerolac and . . . ta-daaah! Yet another brilliant idea! What are we going to do? Let’s use . . . hushed breath . . . drum roll . . . a . . . yes . . . let’s do it . . . use . . . a . . . celebrity. But just to change things a bit, let’s make it a hot guys instead of a hot broad. So . . . here comes . . . Shahrukh Khan.
The next was a predictable, scare-‘em-silly and get sales advertisement. Saffola – predictable and unlikely to convince anybody.
The next showed a man riding a scooter and looking into his rear-view mirror and seeing a Scorpio, then another Mahindra SUV and yet another. Each time, he turns around to see nothing behind him. The ad was for Mahindra Scooters and suggested that Mahindra is behind all its products. Good stuff. Interesting, unlikely and intriguing.
Gillette was the usual predictable P&G rubbish.
Then came Aliva and . . . sorry boss, I’ve got an idea . . . not just a Celebrity! One celebrity in a Double Role (whooo!) and to make it really sexy let’s put her into her only really sexy role. Let me lay on you . . . the sexy, the talented, the amazing  . . . Vidya Balan!
Oh boy! And if that wasn’t enough, we had Garnier Light Fairness Moisturizer starring Priyanka Chopra on an off-day. Evidently, the film’s director was overly impressed by her star power and didn’t tell her, “Priyanka darling, they’re paying you money, try to behave like you mean it – not as if you came in for two hours, faked the whole thing and ran away.”
And another predictable and boring ad for Colgate Sensitive Pro-relief – man in a white coat, whom we are expected to believe is a doctor (way too perfect and way too pretty and way too fake). Okay, let me stop there.
Yomil was an interesting advertisement in comparison to all that.
Then we’re back to all those practical demonstrations of how Indian advertising has basically latched on to Japanese ideas, which are, “Demonstration! Celebrity! Image!” and we have Choc On – with (Surprise! Surprise!) yet another celebrity the fair and lovely but oh-so-very-bland Katrina Kaif.
The next was a prototypical “client wants” commercial for Kisna Diamond Jewelery. “Client wants to show gifting!” “Yes boss!” “Client wants to show a wedding!” “Yes boss!” “Client wants to show relationship between father and daughter” “Yes boss!” “And of course, client wants to show lots of diamonds!” “Yes boss!”
Everything.
And yet another P&G classic for Head and Shoulders. Yes sir! A person in a white coat throwing off technical-sounding balderdash to convince you. But this time, just to make things different let’s make the doctor a pretty blonde.
Now came the ancient American art-form; slice-of-life. It began with an advertisement for Badshah – very fake looking family, incredibly badly acted. There’s a nice word to describe that: obnoxious.
Then, to my horror, came Castrol Activ – ditto.
Okay, so what’s the point?
The point is that nothing much has changed in the last thirty years. For every ten commercials, there will be one good one. (Sturgeon’s Law Rules!) And that’s going to be true of the future as well. Not that there aren’t any good commercials – the Ultrabook commercials, the Airtel commercials (some of them – the ones with the wooden-faced Teutonic drivers are pitiful enough to make you cry) are examples, but there are a plethora of truly pathetic commercials out there. As there always were and always will be.
You may ask, what about other media? And my answer is, well, what about it?
I don’t remember the last time I saw a decent press advertisement. Or a decent hoarding. Or a decent poster.
Every copywriter and art director is concentrating on only one thing.
TV commercials.
Which is cool. That’s where fame (and a Cannes Award) lies.
What about the future?
I think the proliferation of media will continue. We will see more and more specialist channels and there will be a requirement for specialist agencies and specialist creative people. There will also be the need for longer commercials, because the cost of media on specialist channels will be lower.
Press is not going to be left behind, but I think agencies are going to have to get back to understanding and using press effectively. I also believe that good writing and good design are going to get more and more important – the net is fundamentally based on words and design. The moving picture actually has a very small role to play here – especially when it comes to advertising.
Of course, the internet will play a bigger role, but I don’t think that will affect the quality (or lack of it) of commercials and advertising.
In short, to quote the French, “Plus ça change, plus c’est la meme chose.”
As a business, advertising will have to change the way it works from concentrating on media to concentrating on ideas. But that’s something all the truly great agencies have always done, so again, “Plus ça change, plus c’est la meme chose.”
As the great Bill Bernbach said, “All of us who professionally use the mass media are the shapers of society. We can vulgarize that society. We can brutalize it. Or we can help lift it onto a higher level.”
True yesterday. True today. True tomorrow.

1 comment:

Stonethrowers Rants said...

Welcome back!