Tuesday, May 08, 2012

The One Show Rewards Incompetence

I've been watching some old friends post their One Show awards on Facebook. I'm actually embarrassed on their behalves.

How can anybody be so shameless as to post scam ads on a social networking site and actually be proud that they've won an award?

It reminds me of what happens when you're playing a game. It's always easier to hit a six when it doesn't matter. At the nets you'll see some tigers, but when it comes to the match, there's this soft hissing sound and all the courage drains out of them.

The same thing happens in golf: you have some tigers on the range, but once they hit the course . . . the same hissing sound. If you've played tennis you'll notice how often you're able to hit a sizzler straight down the line – once the point is won or lost.

I can go on, but I don't think I need to.

It's easy to hit a home run, win an award, when it doesn't matter. When it's not serious. There's nothing to gloat about when you hit a six against your neighbor's five-year-old. Just like Sachin Tendulkar has nothing to be proud of by scoring a century against Bangladesh.

I saw the ads that won the One Show Pencils.

Yep. I saw them alright.

On the One Show website.

Okay, so they must have appeared . . . somewhere.

Maybe in the local newspaper in Meesamari or Dindigal?

But they weren't real ads, they were done for the awards. And we're all so proud (whoopee!) our copywriters and art directors can actually win One Show and Cannes Awards.

Bobby Pawar can bitch as much as he likes about what Piyush said at the Ad Club, but the Volkswagen advertisement that won a Gold only appeared in some out of the way edition of some out of the way newspaper. There's not getting around that - especially because it's for a car that VW is not really pushing in India.

Sorry Bobby, you've nothing to be proud of until you've won those awards for a genuine ad for a genuine client - like Piyush and his boys did actually with the Fevicol commercial at Cannes.

All these guys - servicing guys incidentally - showing off the Pencils their agencies have won for scams are only showing their own ineptitude. They are unable to develop enough of a relationship with their clients to get them to buy award-winning advertising.

Which is a sad reflection on their own competence.

But more than that, it's a sad reflection on Indian advertising and its unhealthy obsession with awards.

Sad, sad, sad.

No comments: