Why do you suppose companies allow advertising agencies to take them for a ride?
Or do you think companies bully the advertising agencies into delivering low-brow, shallow, advertising that works about as well as India's Government-owned companies?
A bit of both I believe.
Look at Airtel. They're trying to own coverage - that's pretty obvious. Nice and old-fashioned strategy. Don't they know that life has moved a bit beyond owning a functional attribute? In addition, the argument for coverage has a few gaping flaws:
1. Nobody has coverage so good that they have no blank spots or areas of weak coverage. And the instant another operator's name pops up on your Cellphone's screen, you know that they're full of the stuff that comes out of the rear end of a bull.
2. Coverage is table stakes. You cannot function without coverage.
3. You're completely ignoring the fact that Airtel know encompasses landline services as well.
So, in my view - I maybe wrong, but I'm not - coverage has to be given an emotional tinge. For example how about making Airtel the most 'accessible' of all services. You find that this will cover landline, cellular and every other type of service in addition to your own standards of 'service' in the old sense. Airtel has the best: ie the most helpful polite call centre.
Sounds simple doesn't it?
But if this makes sense the advertising doesn't.
I mean if you qualifity your service as "accessible", then how accessible is a couple who can afford to fly over nice virgin forests? How accessible is a little girl in an expensive boarding school? How accessible is a boy who has a girlfriend who's obviously slumming it in a village school? (Somebody called this the 'romanticization' of rural India and well, yes, it is). Most of all, you end up realizing that mere coverage doesn't really cut it.
But if you have work that gets through after a show of aggressiveness and assertiveness by a senior guy in the agency, then that's the work you get out.
Garbage.
Anybody disagree?
Anybody listening?
Do tell.
Cheers.
No comments:
Post a Comment